Three cities, three ways of hearing the same word
Before taking the next step with Paul, come back with me to where we left him. Acts 16 ended in Philippi. That miniature Roman colony, proud of its citizenship, had thrown Paul and Silas into prison without a trial, and God had answered with an earthquake at midnight, with the jailer converted and baptized with his whole household, and with the magistrates embarrassed into apologizing when they found out they had beaten Roman citizens. Paul did not run off: he stopped at Lydia’s house, encouraged the brothers and only then left, leaving behind him the first church planted on European soil. The seed had crossed the sea. Now it is going to travel down the great road and be thrown onto three different kinds of ground, and this is where our reading begins.
Because this chapter is, above all, a study of how people hear. The same word, the same preacher, the same Christ proclaimed, and three reactions that could not be more different. In Thessalonica, the word provokes a riot of jealousy. In Berea, it finds hearts that examine it gladly. In Athens, it runs into the cold curiosity of the philosophers, who find it interesting and nothing more. Luke leads us through three cities the way one might lead us past three mirrors: in which of them do we recognize ourselves when the truth reaches us?
“As his manner was”: three Sabbaths that shook a city
Now when they had passed through Amphipolis and Apollonia, they came to Thessalonica, where was a synagogue of the Jews: And Paul, as his manner was, went in unto them, and three sabbath days reasoned with them out of the scriptures, Opening and alleging, that Christ must needs have suffered, and risen again from the dead; and that this Jesus, whom I preach unto you, is Christ.Acts 17:1–3
Notice the route before you notice the city. Amphipolis (50 km), Apollonia (93 km), Thessalonica (150 km): Luke is following the line of the Via Egnatia1, the great Roman road that cut across Macedonia from east to west, linking the Adriatic Sea to the Aegean. Paul is not wandering at random through the backcountry; he travels the main artery of the empire, from big city to big city, where there are people, trade and a synagogue. Thessalonica was the largest of them: capital of the province of Macedonia, a busy port, a free city with its own government. If the word took hold there, it would run along the road on its own in both directions. And that is what happened: Paul would later write that from there “sounded out the word of the Lord” throughout the region (1 Thessalonians 1:8).
Now the method. “Paul, as his manner was, went in unto them”: the text preserves here a detail worth lingering over. Paul’s custom, wherever he arrived, was to go first to the synagogue. Not out of cold strategy, but out of conviction: the gospel was, for him, the fulfillment of the promise made to Israel, and therefore it had to be offered to Israel first. “To the Jew first” (Romans 1:16) is not a stray phrase: it is the practice of a whole life. He enters the house of prayer of his own people, opens the same scrolls they revere, and from there, from inside the Scriptures that both accept, he reasons.
And see what he does with the scrolls, because this is the heart of his method. The verb Luke uses is strong: Paul “reasoned”: διελέγετο (dielégeto), from which we get “dialogue”: not a pulpit sermon, but open reasoning, a back-and-forth of arguments, almost a debate. And the content of that debate had two points, expressed in two verbs Luke chooses with care: “opening” (διανοίγων, dianoígōn, literally that: opening, as one opens something that was shut) and “alleging” (παρατιθέμενος, paratithémenos, literally setting beside, presenting the evidence). First he opens the sacred text and shows what it really says; then he sets the evidence beside it, comparing prophecy with fulfillment. Open and prove. That is how the Bible is taught.
And what did he need to open and prove? Only one thing, but it was a stumbling block to the Jewish mind: that Christ must needs have suffered, and risen again from the dead. That “must needs,” ἔδει (édei), carries the weight of a divine obligation, of something written into God’s plan from all eternity. Stop here and understand the difficulty, because without it the chapter loses its force. The first-century Jew expected a victorious Messiah: a king who would break the yoke of Rome, restore the throne of David and reign in glory. The idea of a Messiah who suffers, who is rejected, who dies on a cross, the accursed death according to the Law itself (Deuteronomy 21:23), was a scandal, a contradiction. A crucified Messiah sounded, to their ears, like a contradiction in terms: how could God’s Anointed end up cursed on the tree?
That is why Paul had to open the Scriptures. He was not inventing a new Messiah; he was showing that the suffering Messiah was already there, in the pages they read every Sabbath without seeing. He was in Isaiah 53, in the servant who “was wounded for our transgressions,” who “hath poured out his soul unto death.” He was in Psalm 22, in the pierced righteous one who cries, “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?” He was in Psalm 16, in the Holy One whose body would not see corruption. He was in the promise to David, in the figure of the Passover lamb, in the goat sent out into the wilderness. The proofs were scattered throughout the Old Testament: it only needed to be opened with the right eyes. And the climax of it all, the sharp point of the argument, was the identification: “this Jesus, whom I preach unto you, is Christ.” The Messiah of the Scriptures has a name, and the name is Jesus of Nazareth.
And some of them believed, and consorted with Paul and Silas; and of the devout Greeks a great multitude, and of the chief women not a few.Acts 17:4
The harvest came, but look at its makeup, because it explains the fight that follows. Three groups believed. First, “some” of the Jews, a minority of the synagogue’s regulars. Second, and this is the large group, “of the devout Greeks a great multitude”: the so-called God-fearers, Gentiles who had grown tired of pagan idolatry and drawn near to the God of Israel, attending the synagogue, attracted by its ethics and its monotheism, but without submitting to circumcision. They were people with seeking hearts, half inside and half outside, and the gospel, which offered full sonship without the yoke of the Law, fell on them like rain on dry ground. Third, “of the chief women not a few”: wives of the city’s leading men, women of influence. This is how the church of Thessalonica is born: a handful of Jews, a crowd of seeking Greeks and women of the elite. And it is precisely this crowd of Gentiles (who were, so to speak, “within arm’s reach” inside the synagogue) that will set off the jealousy.
“These that have turned the world upside down are come hither also”
But the Jews which believed not, moved with envy, took unto them certain lewd fellows of the baser sort, and gathered a company, and set all the city on an uproar, and assaulted the house of Jason, and sought to bring them out to the people.Acts 17:5
Find the root of it all in a single word: envy. The Greek is ζῆλος (zêlos), from which come both “zeal” and “jealousy”: a heat of the soul that can be holy or can be poison, depending on its object. Here it is poison. And it is worth understanding what they are jealous over, because this is no ordinary envy. Those God-fearing Gentiles (the devout Greeks, the leading women) were, in the synagogue’s eyes, its own harvest. Years of patient witness had drawn them near. They were the fruit of the Jewish community’s labor, the proof that the God of Israel was drawing the nations. And then Paul arrives, preaches for three Sabbaths, and in a moment takes away precisely that group, offering freely, without circumcision, without the yoke, full citizenship in the people of God. The jealousy is not abstract: it is the jealousy of someone who sees his own barn emptied by a newcomer.
And this jealousy is not an accident of Thessalonica: it is a thread that runs through Paul’s whole journey. Luke uses the same word in Pisidian Antioch, where, “when the Jews saw the multitudes, they were filled with envy” (Acts 13:45); in Iconium, the unbelieving Jews “stirred up the Gentiles, and made their minds evil affected against the brethren” (Acts 14:2); and the hostility even travels after him, when men from Antioch and Iconium stone him at Lystra (Acts 14:19). It is always the same trigger, God-fearing Gentiles embracing the gospel, and always the same reaction from someone who sees his own barn emptied by a newcomer. What happens in Thessalonica, then, is no exception: it is the portrait of a pattern.
And see how low jealousy brings respectable people. The synagogue leaders (men of the Law, zealous for holiness) go looking for allies among “certain lewd fellows of the baser sort” (in the English of the King James, lewd means worthless, not obscene), in the marketplace. Stop and feel the bitter irony: the guardians of the Torah, to stop the gospel, join forces with the very riffraff they despise. When the truth is uncomfortable and arguments run out, there is always the resort to the mob and to force. They could not refute Paul from the Scriptures, so they hired disorder.
And when they found them not, they drew Jason and certain brethren unto the rulers of the city, crying, These that have turned the world upside down are come hither also; Whom Jason hath received: and these all do contrary to the decrees of Cæsar, saying that there is another king, one Jesus.Acts 17:6–7
The immediate target was Paul, but he was not at home, so they seized the host. Jason is the name of the man who had lodged the missionaries, and that is why the mob “assaulted the house of Jason.” The Bible says little about this man. He was a kinsman of Paul (Romans 16:21). Notice the cost of opening the door to the gospel: to host Paul, in that city, was to sign your name under the danger. Jason paid for a good deed. And, not finding the preachers, they drew Jason and certain brethren before the politarchs, the rulers of the city. A small and precious detail: Luke calls these magistrates πολιτάρχας (politárchas), a very rare title that critics long judged to be Luke’s mistake, since it did not appear in any known classical text. Until archaeology unearthed, in Thessalonica itself, stone inscriptions using exactly this term for the local rulers. Luke was right, and the critics were wrong.2
Listen to the accusation, because in it there is, unintentionally, one of the greatest compliments ever paid to the early church. “These that have turned the world upside down.” The verb anastatóō means to turn upside down, to stir up, to subvert. The enemies meant to insult and ended up prophesying. Yes, that is exactly what the gospel was doing: turning the world upside down. And notice the precision of the complaint: they said “the world,” the oikoumenē, the whole inhabited world. That handful of men with no army, no money and no power was already perceived as a force capable of shaking the empire. The perception was entirely right.
And the formal accusation was political, calculated to alarm Rome: “these all do contrary to the decrees of Cæsar, saying that there is another king, one Jesus.” Here things get serious. To proclaim “another king” besides Caesar was majestas, treason against the emperor, a capital crime. The accusers were clever: they turned a theological question into a threat of sedition. And the most striking thing is that, in one sense, they were not lying. The Christians really did proclaim another King. They called Jesus Κύριος (Kýrios), Lord, the same title the imperial cult reserved for Caesar. They confessed a Kingdom that did not come from Rome and that would outlive Rome. Their supreme loyalty was not to Caesar’s throne, but to God’s throne. The enemies understood this better than many lukewarm Christians today: the lordship of Christ is total, and a total lordship always relativizes every other. Where Jesus is truly King, no Caesar is absolute.
And this tactic was not new: it was exactly the one they had already used against Jesus himself. Before Pilate, they likewise swapped the real accusation, a religious one, for a politicized version: “We found this fellow perverting the nation (…) saying that he himself is Christ a King” (Luke 23:2). And it was with the same lever that they pressed the governor: “If thou let this man go, thou art not Cæsar’s friend: whosoever maketh himself a king speaketh against Cæsar” (John 19:12), down to the final cry, “We have no king but Cæsar” (John 19:15). The mechanism is identical to Thessalonica’s: where the truth about Christ’s kingship could not be refuted, it was denounced as treason. And, as with the title Pilate had fastened to the cross, “THE KING OF THE JEWS” (John 19:19), once again the accusation proclaimed, unintentionally, the purest truth.
Upside down: the gospel as the subversion of the world
It is worth pausing the narrative to pull on this thread, because the enemies’ cry in Thessalonica, that these men had “turned the world upside down,” touches the nerve of all Scripture. It was no passing exaggeration. This is what God does, from beginning to end: he inverts the order that people consider natural. And when you go through the Bible with this in view, you see that the gospel did not fall into a neutral world: it fell into an upside-down world, and came to set it right side up again, which, to someone who is upside down, feels like being the one turned over.
Begin with Mary’s mouth, before Jesus was even born. In the Magnificat, the young woman of Nazareth sings the program of the Kingdom she carries in her womb: God “hath put down the mighty from their seats, and exalted them of low degree. He hath filled the hungry with good things; and the rich he hath sent empty away” (Luke 1:52–53). Notice the scandal of this song. Everything the world piles on top (throne, power, wealth) God knocks down; everything the world tramples underfoot (the humble, the hungry, the empty) God lifts up. The Kingdom arrives and the pyramid is turned over. Mary was not writing pretty poetry; she was announcing a revolution of values that would begin in the cradle and never stop.
Jesus made it explicit teaching. “The last shall be first, and the first last” (Matthew 20:16): said not once but several times, because it goes against everything we carry in our chests. “Whosoever will be great among you, let him be your minister; And whosoever will be chief among you, let him be your servant” (Matthew 20:26–27). In the world, you climb by stepping on others; in the Kingdom, you climb by serving. “Whosoever shall exalt himself shall be abased; and he that shall humble himself shall be exalted” (Matthew 23:12). Each of these sayings is a shovel that turns over the soil of our instincts. The whole Sermon on the Mount is this: blessed are the poor, those who mourn, the meek, the persecuted, exactly the ones the world declares defeated. Jesus calls happy those whom the earth calls failures. It is the world turned over.
And this King was revealed not on a throne of gold but on a cross. Here is the supreme inversion, the one that gives meaning to all the others. God’s power is revealed in weakness; victory, in apparent defeat; life, through death. Paul measured this folly well: “the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness (…) the foolishness of God is wiser than men; and the weakness of God is stronger than men” (1 Corinthians 1:18, 25). The supreme symbol of Roman shame and torture becomes the revelation of the King of the universe. No human mind would invent a Lord like that. A King who wins by dying turns upside down every idea we have of victory.
Rabbinic wisdom, in its own way, sniffed out this same inversion within Israel’s own Scriptures. The sages noticed, with amazement, that God insists on passing over the natural order: he always chooses the unlikely one. Not Cain the firstborn, but Abel; not Ishmael, the elder, but Isaac; not Esau, who was born first, but Jacob, who came out clutching his brother’s heel; not the older and sturdier brothers, but Joseph, the second youngest, and later David, the youngest, forgotten out in the pasture, whom his own father did not think to call when Samuel came to anoint a king (1 Samuel 16:11). The Midrash on Genesis3 notes this pattern as a divine signature: God does not follow the human right of the firstborn. He chooses the least, the barren, the rejected, so that it may be clear that the strength is his and not that of the flesh. Rashi4, commenting on why the choice always falls on the unlikely one, points to the same lesson: divine election dismantles the human pride of precedence. Israel itself, says Deuteronomy, was not chosen for being great, but because it was “the fewest of all people” (Deuteronomy 7:7). The God of the Bible has a preference for what the world discards, and here the Jewish reading and the Christian one join hands.
Where the two readings part ways (and it is worth marking this, without erasing the convergence) is in how far the inversion goes. For the rabbinic tradition, God raises the humble and brings down the proud within the history of Israel and of the world. For the New Testament, the inversion reaches its unthinkable extreme: the Son himself, the Logos through whom all things were made, “made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant (…) he humbled himself, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross” (Philippians 2:7–8). What was highest goes down to the lowest, so that the lowest may be lifted up.
Now go back to Jason’s house with this thread in hand. When the mob shouted that those men had “turned the world upside down,” it was saying more than it knew. The gospel is subversive: not with swords, but with an inversion of values so radical that no throne, no power, no pride is left standing before it. It topples the rich from their confidence and lifts the poor from their shame; it strips the righteous of their presumption and welcomes the repentant sinner; it undresses the strong and clothes the weak. A King revealed on a cross relativizes all the Caesars who reign from thrones. That is why the world, which is upside down, feels that it is the one being turned over when the Kingdom arrives. And it is: it is being set, at last, right side up again.
And they troubled the people and the rulers of the city, when they heard these things. And when they had taken security of Jason, and of the other, they let them go.Acts 17:8–9
The scene closes with a tense relief. The rulers of the city were “troubled,” and with reason, since a charge of sedition against Caesar could cost them their office, or their heads, if badly handled. But instead of condemning, they “had taken security of Jason”: a bond, a guarantee that there would be no more uproar. That was enough to let them go. But the bond had a hidden price: it obliged Jason to vouch for his guests’ good conduct, which in practice meant that Paul had to leave the city so as not to compromise his host. That is why, in the next verse, the brothers send him away “by night.” The gospel had taken root in Thessalonica, a root that Paul’s two letters to that church would show to be alive and fervent, but the instrument had to leave in a hurry, under cover of darkness, leaving the new believers in the hands of God’s grace and of the persecution that was already on its way. Not every seed that is sown costs the same. This one cost dearly from the very first night.
Who were the Bereans? A faith that checks before it applauds
And the brethren immediately sent away Paul and Silas by night unto Berea: who coming thither went into the synagogue of the Jews.Acts 17:10
Are only “Paul and Silas” sent to Berea? Timothy, however, is still on the team: he reappears a few verses later, when “Silas and Timotheus abode there still” in Berea (Acts 17:14), and later they catch up with Paul in Corinth (Acts 18:5). Luke simply highlights the two leaders and leaves the younger man in the background. And Luke himself? Judging by the “we sections” of Acts, the passages narrated in the first person plural, he had joined the group at Troas (Acts 16:10) and gone with them into Philippi; but there the “we” stops (Acts 16:40) and only reappears years later, in Philippi again (Acts 20:5–6), a sign that he stayed in that city to strengthen the young church. That is why the journey from Thessalonica to Athens is told from the outside: the narrator himself was not there. We leave Thessalonica by the back door, at night, and travel some seventy kilometers down to Berea: a smaller city, farther from the great road, a quieter place. And notice that Paul, as soon as he arrives, does the same thing again: he “went into the synagogue of the Jews.” He had just been driven out of one synagogue because of a bloody riot, and the first thing he does in the next city is walk into another synagogue. No trauma turns him from the method, no scare erases the conviction “to the Jew first”. Persecution changes Paul’s geography, never his strategy. He was chased out of one house of prayer and walked straight into the next. It is this holy stubbornness that opens what comes next, one of the most beautiful scenes in the whole Book of Acts.
These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.Acts 17:11
This verse is one of the most important we will ever study together, because in it the Holy Spirit, through Luke’s pen, defines what a noble hearer of the word is, and the definition goes against almost everything that is called faith today. Start with the word “noble.” The Greek is εὐγενέστεροι (eugenésteroi), literally “well-born,” of better stock. Luke is saying that the Bereans had a nobility of soul superior to that of the Thessalonians. And what did this nobility consist of? Not in being more credulous, more enthusiastic, easier to convince. Exactly the opposite: in being more discerning.
Look at the two halves of this nobility, because they must walk together or one corrupts the other. First half: “they received the word with all readiness of mind”: with complete readiness, with an open heart, without the sulky jealousy of Thessalonica. They were not skeptics with folded arms, hoping to find a flaw. They were willing to listen, eager even. Second half, and here is the point: they “searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.” They received with an open heart and checked with the Bible in hand. Openness without naivety; enthusiasm with verification. They listened to the greatest apostle who ever lived, and even so they went home to open the scrolls and check whether what he said matched what was written. For anyone who wants to do the same today, with their own Bible open, the step-by-step is in how to read the Bible and understand what you read.
“Searched” translates ἀνακρίνοντες (anakrínontes), a term from legal vocabulary: it was what was done in a court, the careful investigation of a case, the cross-examination of the evidence before passing sentence. It is not a passing read; it is an inquiry. The Bereans judged Paul’s preaching before the court of the Scriptures. And notice two details Luke makes a point of recording. First, “daily”: not once out of curiosity, but every day, with discipline, as a habit of life. Second, the standard was “the scriptures”: the measuring rod was not Paul’s eloquence, nor his charisma, nor the signs that accompanied him, but the sacred text they already had. The Bereans’ question was not “What an impressive man!” but “Is it really so?”
Stop and let the lesson burn, because it judges us too. The Bereans did not accept the word because Paul was Paul. They accepted it after verifying that it was true. And Luke, inspired by the Holy Spirit, calls this nobility, not rebellion, not lack of faith, not intellectual arrogance. Hold on to this firmly: the faith the Bible praises is not the one that swallows everything that comes from the pulpit; it is the one that checks everything in the light of the Scriptures. The mature believer is not the one who applauds the loudest, but the one who examines the best. At a time when listeners are asked to “just believe,” not to question the anointed, to receive without weighing, the Holy Spirit points to Berea and says: these were the noble ones. The most authoritative preaching in history submitted, without complaint, to the examination of ordinary people with open Bibles. If Paul accepted being checked, who is the preacher who demands to be believed without checking? And the examination does not apply only to the pulpit: it applies to everything asserted before us, including the day’s headline. That is what I did in the study on Israel and Iran, taking the sentence everyone repeats, that it is an age-old hatred, and checking whether it is really so.
And this is not a compliment to be framed: it is a working method. In Can a Christian play the Mega-Sena? (in Portuguese; the Mega-Sena is Brazil’s national lottery) I apply exactly the Berean examination to a question the whole country is debating: reading what Scripture says, and also what it does not say, before drawing a conclusion.
Therefore many of them believed; also of honourable women which were Greeks, and of men, not a few.Acts 17:12
And see the fruit of the examination: “Therefore many of them believed.” This is the point that undoes a common misunderstanding: that examining is a sign of doubt, and that whoever checks too much ends up not believing. It was the reverse. Precisely because they examined, they believed, and many believed. The honest examination of the Scriptures did not draw them away from Christ; it led them to him. The truth does not fear investigation; it invites it, because it is by looking closely that it proves itself true. Those who checked most carefully were the ones who believed most firmly. A faith that has passed through the court of the text and come out standing is a faith that persecution does not easily knock down. It is no accident that the church in Berea left behind it not a reputation for riots, but the reputation of a people who knew why they believed.
The Berean test: Scripture as the court that judges every sermon
It is worth interrupting the journey to settle this principle with the full weight of the Bible, because what the Bereans did in one moment is, in fact, a command that runs through both Testaments. The idea that the believer must test, weigh and examine everything he is taught is neither a Protestant invention nor the stubbornness of suspicious people: it is a command of God, repeated from the beginning to the end of the Scriptures. Berea was not a praiseworthy exception; it was obedience to a rule that should be the norm for all of God’s people.
The Torah itself already taught Israel to test a prophet before following him. Moses gave Israel a hard criterion: “When a prophet speaketh in the name of the LORD, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the LORD hath not spoken” (Deuteronomy 18:22). And, more radical still, even the prophet whose sign comes true must be rejected if he teaches the people to go after other gods (Deuteronomy 13:1–3): God commands us to measure the messenger by the message, and the message by the truth already revealed. There is no duty, in the Bible, to follow anyone blindly. There is the duty to discern. The task of examining is not the distrust of a hard heart; it is obedience to the God who never asked for blind faith, but for grounded faith.
Isaiah sharpened this into a sentence that became a motto: “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them” (Isaiah 8:20). It is all there. “The law” and “the testimony,” the revealed word, are the touchstone. Any teaching, no matter who it comes from, however spiritual it sounds, must be held up against this standard. If it does not match, “there is no light.” The criterion is not experience, not goose bumps, not the preacher’s success: it is conformity with what God has already said. Isaiah is commanding the people to do, centuries in advance, exactly what the Bereans would do: bring every new voice before the court of the old word.
Paul, the same man who was checked in Berea, wrote: “Prove all things; hold fast that which is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21), and he wrote it precisely to the Thessalonians, as if to tell them: be more like your neighbors in Berea. John was even more direct: “Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world” (1 John 4:1). “Believe not every spirit”: in other words, do not swallow everything that presents itself as coming from God. Try it. And Jesus himself, near the end of the Sermon on the Mount, warned: “Beware of false prophets (…) Ye shall know them by their fruits” (Matthew 7:15–16). Knowing them by their fruits is also examining before accepting.
Israel’s tradition made examination not an isolated gesture but a way of studying, and here there is a beautiful convergence with the spirit of Berea. Rabbinic study of the Torah was never passive reception; it is debate, question, the clash of arguments. The very term that describes the study of the oral tradition, תַּלְמוּד (talmud), comes from the root lamad, to learn by teaching and questioning. In the pages of the Talmud, no statement passes without being interrogated: the question is asked, “minhá hanei milei?”, “from where do we know this?”, demanding that every thesis be proved from the text. The sages called pilpul the sharp analysis that tests each opinion, turning it on every side before accepting it. A saying in the Mishnah sums up the ideal: “Turn it, and again turn it; for the all is therein” (Pirkei Avot 5:22, tr. Charles Taylor): the word must be turned over, examined, searched through, not merely heard. The Berean who went home to open the scrolls “daily” was, without knowing it, doing what Israel’s best teachers taught: that truth is won by examining, not by swallowing.
The Bereans examined the Scriptures and concluded that Jesus was the Messiah, a reading that the majority of the synagogue rejected then and rejects to this day. In other words, the same reverent method of examining the text led faithful Jews to opposite conclusions. This does not cancel the principle; it illuminates it. The examination of the Scriptures is not a machine that produces the right answer on its own: it is a discipline that depends on who examines and with what heart. The Bereans had both halves: an open heart and textual rigor. Without the first, rigor becomes a wall against the truth; without the second, openness becomes superstition. Both are needed, and that is why Luke praises them together.
Gather up, then, what Berea leaves us as a permanent norm. No preacher is above examination; not even Paul was. No anointing exempts anyone from being checked; Paul’s did not. The measuring rod for every sermon, every teaching, every supposed move of the Spirit is always the same: what do the Scriptures say? Whoever receives without weighing does not have greater faith, but more fragile faith; and whoever examines with an open heart does not have less faith, but the faith the Bible itself calls noble. This text you hold in your hands asks exactly this of you: do not believe a single line because it is written here: check each one with your Bible open, like the people of Berea. If anything here does not match the sacred text, stay with the sacred text. That is what it is for. The word of God is not afraid of being checked; it is the very rod by which everything else is checked.
But when the Jews of Thessalonica had knowledge that the word of God was preached of Paul at Berea, they came thither also, and stirred up the people. And then immediately the brethren sent away Paul to go as it were to the sea: but Silas and Timotheus abode there still. And they that conducted Paul brought him unto Athens: and receiving a commandment unto Silas and Timotheus for to come to him with all speed, they departed.Acts 17:13–15
The peace of Berea did not last long, and the reason is revealing. The enemies from Thessalonica, on learning that Paul was preaching there too, “came thither also”: they traveled the seventy kilometers on purpose, just to stir up the crowds. Notice the size of this hatred: it was not enough for them to drive him out of their own city; they hunted him from city to city, like someone chasing a fire to put it out before it catches. It is jealousy turned into a crusade. And once again the brothers act quickly to protect the apostle: they send Paul away “to go as it were to the sea,” probably an escape route to throw the pursuers off his trail, while Silas and Timothy stay in Berea to strengthen the new believers. Notice the church’s care: they do not expose Paul recklessly, nor do they abandon the new converts. They take the target out of danger and leave shepherds behind. And so, escorted by devoted brothers, Paul arrives in Athens: alone, waiting for his companions, in the city that was the brain of the ancient world. What he will find there will not be a mob of envious men, but something subtler and, in its own way, harder: the polite indifference of people who find the truth merely… interesting.
It is worth measuring this escape on the map. Berea is present-day Veria, at the foot of Mount Vermio, in Greek Macedonia; from there to Athens is about three hundred kilometers as the crow flies, and well over five hundred by the dirt roads, which ran down through Thessaly and crossed Thermopylae and Boeotia on a walk of two to three weeks. That is why the verse’s “to the sea” is significant: instead of the long, exposed road, the brothers take Paul some thirty kilometers to the coast of the Thermaic Gulf and put him on a ship bound for Piraeus, the port of Athens: a faster route and, above all, a safer one against those pursuing him by land.
Athens: a city full of gods and empty of the living God
Now while Paul waited for them at Athens, his spirit was stirred in him, when he saw the city wholly given to idolatry.Acts 17:16
Before hearing a word of the speech, we need to see what Paul saw, because the greatest sermon in the Book of Acts is born of an emotion, not a strategy. He is alone in Athens, waiting for Silas and Timothy, with time on his hands. And what does a monotheistic Jew do with free time in the cultural capital of paganism? He walks, he looks, and what he sees stirs him. Hold on to the scene: Paul does not arrive in Athens with a campaign plan in his head. He arrives as a reluctant tourist, and the city wounds his soul.
What city was this? Athens was no longer the political power it had once been; Rome had long since eclipsed it. But it was still the brain of the ancient world, the university of the empire, the land of Socrates, Plato and Aristotle, the place where Greek philosophy had reached its peak. It was also an open-air museum of religion: temples, altars, statues everywhere. Ancient writers said, with some exaggeration, that in Athens it was easier to find a god than a man.5 There were more images of divinities in the streets than citizens in the squares. The city was at once the summit of human intelligence and the depths of religious confusion, living proof that the genius of the mind does not cure the blindness of the heart before God.
And this is where Luke’s word must be weighed carefully, because it reveals Paul’s heart. “His spirit was stirred in him”: the Greek is παρωξύνετο (parōxýneto), and you have already met this root in the previous study: it is the same as in paroxysmós, the sharp contention between Paul and Barnabas. It is a word of deep irritation, of indignation that boils. The Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible, the Septuagint, used this same verb to describe the wrath of God provoked by Israel’s idolatry. This is not the aesthetic discomfort of someone who dislikes statues; it is God’s grief reflected in the apostle’s soul. Before those idols, Paul feels something of what God feels, a holy distress at seeing the glory that belongs only to the Creator scattered over stones and metals.
Paul could have admired Athens like any cultured traveler: what architecture, what art, what refinement! And there was indeed beauty there. But what seized his soul was not the beauty: it was the blindness. He looked behind every magnificent statue and saw lost souls worshiping what is not God. The city “wholly given to idolatry”: the Greek expression, κατείδωλον (kateídōlon), is rare and strong, something like “submerged in idols,” covered with images the way a body is covered with a disease. Where the tourist saw culture, the apostle saw a drowning people. And it was this grief (not calculation, not an agenda) that moved him to speak. The Areopagus sermon is the child of a heart that broke before idolatry. Before he evangelized with his mouth, Paul was moved in his spirit. Whoever is not moved by the lostness of others will hardly have anything true to say to them.
In the synagogue and in the market: the gospel meets the philosophers
Therefore disputed he in the synagogue with the Jews, and with the devout persons, and in the market daily with them that met with him.Acts 17:17
See how emotion becomes action, and notice the faithful method. Moved by that grief, Paul does not stay silent. And he does what he always does: he goes first to dispute “in the synagogue with the Jews, and with the devout persons,” the God-fearers. But Athens demands a second stage, and Paul takes it: “in the market daily with them that met with him.” The “market” is the ἀγορά (agorá), the beating heart of Athens, where people bought, sold, argued and philosophized. And there is a deliciously deliberate historical echo here: it was precisely in the agora of Athens that, centuries before, Socrates used to stop passersby to discuss the truth, and that was why they condemned him to death. Now, in the same place, another man stops the passersby to speak of a God they do not know. Paul becomes a “Socrates of the gospel,” disputing “with them that met with him,” day after day.
Then certain philosophers of the Epicureans, and of the Stoicks, encountered him. And some said, What will this babbler say? other some, He seemeth to be a setter forth of strange gods: because he preached unto them Jesus, and the resurrection.Acts 17:18
And then the gospel runs headlong into the two greatest schools of philosophy of the ancient world, and it is worth knowing them, because Paul is going to speak directly against what they believed. On one side, the Epicureans. They followed Epicurus, for whom the gods, if they existed, lived far away and indifferent, never meddling in human affairs; the world was the product of chance, a random collision of atoms; and the goal of life was to seek serene pleasure and avoid pain. There was no providence, no judgment, no life after death: at death, the atoms scattered and everything was over. On the other side, the Stoics, followers of Zeno. They were pantheists: god was a kind of rational soul diffused throughout the universe, and everything was woven together in an iron fate. Virtue was living “according to nature,” self-sufficient, mastering the passions, accepting fate with serenity. One group said that god does not care; the other, that god is everything and nothing in particular. One preached pleasure; the other, duty. And Paul is going to confront both with a God who is neither distant nor confused with the world: a personal God, Creator and Judge.
Now listen to the contempt with which they received him, because cultured Athens reacts to the truth not with a riot, like Thessalonica, but with polite scorn. Some said, “What will this babbler say?” The Greek word is priceless: σπερμολόγος (spermológos), literally “seed-picker,” the image of a little bird pecking at loose grains on the ground. It was street slang for the chatterbox who picks up scraps of ideas here and there, with no system, and goes around repeating secondhand crumbs. They called Paul a fifth-rate intellectual, a scrap-picker of other people’s ideas. The wise men of Athens looked at the greatest theologian in history and saw a sparrow pecking at crumbs. Others, more respectful, still got it wrong: “He seemeth to be a setter forth of strange gods,” new deities. And Luke explains why, with a phrase that almost smiles: “because he preached unto them Jesus, and the resurrection.” The Athenians, hearing “Jesus” (Ἰησοῦν) and “resurrection” (ἀνάστασιν, anástasin), seem to have understood that Paul was preaching two new gods: one called Jesus (Iesous) and a goddess called Anastasis. The blindness was so great that they turned the good news of the resurrection into a new divinity to add to their already crowded pantheon.
To Mars’ hill: the court that became a pulpit
And they took him, and brought him unto Areopagus, saying, May we know what this new doctrine, whereof thou speakest, is? For thou bringest certain strange things to our ears: we would know therefore what these things mean.Acts 17:19–20
They brought him to the Areopagus, and it is good to know what this place was, because the name carries weight. Ἄρειος πάγος (Áreios págos) means “hill of Ares” (Mars, to the Romans), a rocky outcrop west of the Acropolis. But “Areopagus” also, and above all, designated the oldest and most venerable council of Athens: a kind of supreme court and academy, guardian of the city’s religion, customs and education. It was before this body of elders that it was decided what could or could not be taught publicly in Athens. So the scene has two possible readings, and perhaps both are true at once: either they brought Paul to an informal trial, to give an account of this “new doctrine,” as they had done with Socrates; or they simply led him to the most dignified place in which to hear him attentively. Either way, the most respected court of the pagan world is about to become, for an hour, the pulpit of the gospel.
Notice the question they put to him, because it opens the door Paul is about to walk through: “May we know what this new doctrine, whereof thou speakest, is?” There was curiosity, but it was a cold curiosity, a collector’s curiosity. They do not ask “Is it true?” as the Bereans did; they ask “What novelty is this?” They want a new piece for their collection of ideas, not a truth to transform their lives. And Luke, with a touch of a historian’s irony, explains the city’s mood in the next verse.
(For all the Athenians and strangers which were there spent their time in nothing else, but either to tell, or to hear some new thing.)Acts 17:21
This parenthesis of Luke’s6 is a devastating portrait, and a mirror for every age. The Athenians “spent their time in nothing else, but either to tell, or to hear some new thing.” The Greek expression is “telling or hearing something newer”: καινότερον (kainóteron), the comparative, like someone always chasing the latest of the latest news, something newer than new. Stop and recognize the portrait: a culture addicted to novelty, that was its dopamine, hungry for stimulation, unable to linger over anything, always running after the next interesting idea, and for that very reason unable to commit to any truth. Novelty becomes entertainment; truth becomes one more spectacle to consume and discard. It is the opposite disease to Berea’s. The Bereans listened in order to test and, by testing, they believed. The Athenians listened in order to be entertained and, entertained, moved on in search of the next distraction. The same gospel, the same open ears, but a heart that examines is saved, and a heart that is merely entertained is lost. Before this audience, curious and empty, brilliant and adrift, Paul stands up. And what he says is a masterpiece.
“To the Unknown God”: starting where the listener is
Then Paul stood in the midst of Mars’ hill, and said, Ye men of Athens, I perceive that in all things ye are too superstitious. For as I passed by, and beheld your devotions, I found an altar with this inscription, TO THE UNKNOWN GOD. Whom therefore ye ignorantly worship, him declare I unto you.Acts 17:22–23
Listen to how Paul begins, because the opening is a lesson in wisdom. He stands before the most cultured men in the world, and he does not open with condemnation or with a verse from Isaiah, which would mean nothing to them. He begins where they are. “Ye men of Athens, I perceive that in all things ye are too superstitious.” The Greek word, δεισιδαιμονεστέρους (deisidaimonestérous), is deliberately ambiguous: it could sound like praise (“very religious”) or like criticism (“superstitious”). Paul walks the razor’s edge: he acknowledges that they are an intensely religious people, without thereby blessing their religion. He does not flatter, but neither does he insult from the outset. He finds the point of contact before pointing out the error.
And then he does something brilliant: he uses one of their own altars as a way in. “I found an altar with this inscription, TO THE UNKNOWN GOD.” Such altars really did exist in Athens: ἀγνώστῳ θεῷ (agnṓstōi theôi), “to an unknown god.” The Athenians, afraid of forgetting some divinity and provoking its anger, set up generic altars to cover any god they might have left out. It was the height of their religious insecurity: they worshiped so much that they feared they were not worshiping enough. And Paul takes this altar of confessed ignorance and turns it into a bridge: “Whom therefore ye ignorantly worship, him declare I unto you.”
Measure the brilliance and the boldness of this sentence, because the whole strategy is in it. Paul does not say “I am going to introduce you to a new god,” which would have made him one more spermológos peddling foreign divinities. He says, in essence: “The one you already admit you do not know, the one before whom your wisdom declared itself ignorant and set up a blank altar: this is the one I have come to proclaim.” He does not bring one more god to the crowded pantheon; he brings the God who was missing, the only real one, the one whose absence the Athenians themselves had sensed and confessed in stone. Their ignorance becomes the hook for revelation. Notice the courage too: before the greatest intellectuals in the world, Paul declares that they worship without knowing. The wisdom of Athens, in what matters most, which is knowing God, is learned ignorance. And he is going to fill that void not with speculation but with proclamation: “him declare I unto you.” Not “him I propose for debate.” I declare. Paul does not come to discuss a hypothesis; he comes to reveal the One who can be known.
It is worth knowing where an altar like that might have come from. According to an ancient tradition recorded by Diogenes Laertius, around the sixth century BC a plague was ravaging Athens; when consulted, the oracle of Delphi ordered the city to be purified, and the Athenians brought the seer Epimenides from Crete. The reasoning was this: since they had already sacrificed to all the known gods without relief, it remained to suppose some god not yet identified, an unknown god, who was waiting to be appeased. To find him, Epimenides let hungry sheep loose on the Areopagus early in the morning: on good pasture, a hungry sheep grazes; it does not lie down; if one lay down, against its own nature, that would be the sign that a god was claiming it there. Each sheep that lay down was sacrificed on the very spot “to the appropriate god” of that place, the god responsible, whose name no one knew, and an altar was raised there. When the plague ceased, nameless altars remained around the city, memorials of that atonement. Centuries later, it was before one of these anonymous altars, “to the unknown god,” that Paul took his stand. There is a delightful thread here: the same Epimenides, the Cretan behind this story, is the poet to whom is attributed the line Paul would quote minutes later, “in him we live, and move, and have our being” (Acts 17:28), and whom he would quote again in his letter to Titus (Titus 1:12).7
The God who made everything does not live in what hands make
God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands…Acts 17:24
Now Paul begins to build, brick by brick, who this God is, and each brick knocks down a column of Greek philosophy. First brick: “God that made the world and all things therein.” The word for “world” is κόσμος (kósmos), the ordered universe, the whole. And with these five words Paul demolishes both halves of his audience at once. Against the Epicureans, who believed in a world born of chance, of the blind collision of atoms: no, there is an Author, a will, a design; the cosmos is not an accident, it is a work. Against the Stoics, who believed in a diffuse god, an impersonal soul mixed into the universe: no, God is distinct from his creation; he made the world, so he is not the world. The Creator is not to be confused with the created. In a single sentence, Paul separates God from pantheism and from materialism, and plants the first truth of Genesis before Athens: “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.”
Second brick, which follows from the first: being “Lord of heaven and earth,” this God “dwelleth not in temples made with hands.” It is the same idea that, two chapters later, a silversmith in Ephesus will repeat as an accusation, saying that Paul went around claiming that gods made with hands are not gods. Stop and see the audacity of this, said where it was said. Paul is standing on the Areopagus, and just above him, dominating the landscape, rises the Acropolis, crowned by the Parthenon: the most glorious temple of the Greek world, home of the goddess Athena. In full view of all those magnificent shrines, the apostle declares that the true God does not live in any of them. How could he? The one who made heaven and earth does not fit in a stone box, however beautiful it may be. The temple does not contain God; it is God who contains the temple, and the whole world, and the heaven of heavens.
And here it is worth noting that Paul is not inventing a refined Greek idea: he is preaching the purest Hebrew theology, the same that Solomon had confessed centuries earlier. When Solomon dedicated the temple in Jerusalem, the holiest place Israel ever built, he prayed: “But will God indeed dwell on the earth? behold, the heaven and heaven of heavens cannot contain thee; how much less this house that I have builded?” (1 Kings 8:27). The builder of the temple himself knew that the temple did not contain God. And Isaiah had gone further still, with words that seem written on purpose for the Areopagus: “Thus saith the LORD, The heaven is my throne, and the earth is my footstool: where is the house that ye build unto me? (…) For all those things hath mine hand made” (Isaiah 66:1–2). Paul is simply taking to the Greeks what God had already revealed to Israel: the Creator of all things does not lodge in what hands manufacture.
Neither is worshipped with men’s hands, as though he needed any thing, seeing he giveth to all life, and breath, and all things…Acts 17:25
Third brick, and it is an inversion that turns all pagan religion inside out: this God is not “worshipped with men’s hands, as though he needed any thing.” All ancient religion, and a good part of the religion of every age, ran on the basis of exchange: the gods had to be fed, appeased, served; people offered sacrifices to supply that divine need and to buy heaven’s favor. The gods of Olympus were hungry, vain, full of needs that mortals had to satisfy. And Paul cuts that root in two: the true God needs nothing. No one serves him as if supplying something he lacks, because he lacks nothing. The creature adds nothing to the Creator.
And see how Paul completely reverses the direction of the flow, because here is the heart of the matter. In pagan religion, the flow goes from the bottom up: man gives, the god receives. Paul reverses it: “he giveth to all life, and breath, and all things.” The true flow goes from the top down: it is not we who sustain God, it is God who sustains us at every moment. He gives life, existence itself; he gives breath, πνοήν (pnoḗn), the very breath that fills our lungs right now, without which there would be no next word; and he gives “all things.” There is a direct echo here of Genesis 2:7, when God “breathed into his nostrils the breath of life.” The air the philosophers of Athens were breathing while they mocked Paul was being given to them, at that very moment, by the God they did not know. What madness, then, to imagine that this God depends on our offerings. It is we who depend on him, breath by breath. Idolatry turns the universe upside down: it makes the Giver of everything kneel before the hands that received from him even the strength to kneel.
Of one blood: the God who rules the nations and history
And hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation…Acts 17:26
Paul now lifts his gaze from the individual to the whole of history, and every word continues to demolish a piece of Greek pride. Begin at the root: he “hath made of one blood all nations of men.” Other manuscripts lack the word blood and read only “of one,” but the sense is the same, and it is revolutionary for that audience. The Greeks considered themselves a superior race; they divided humanity into two blocs: the Hellenes, cultured and civilized, and the barbarians, everyone else, inferior people whose very name imitated the unintelligible babble of their speech. And Paul, standing in the heart of Greece, declares that all of humanity (Greeks and barbarians, Athenians and Scythians8, free and slave) is of one blood. A single trunk. A single family. The wall between peoples, which the Greeks held to be natural and sacred, is a fiction: before the Creator, there is only one race, the human race, come from a single original womb. Here, spoken to proud philosophers, is the truth of Adam: all brothers by blood, all creatures of a single earthly ancestor (Adam) made by a single heavenly God.
And see what else Paul affirms about this God: he governs history and geography. He “hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation.” This strikes the Stoics squarely, with their blind fate, that impersonal burden that wove everything together without purpose. No, says Paul, there is no blind fate; there is a God who determines. The “times” of the peoples, the rise and fall of empires, the borders of nations: all of it is under the hand of a personal God who orders the times and draws the boundaries. Athens had had its age of glory and now lived in the shadow of Rome; one day Rome would pass too. No empire is eternal, because above them all there is the One who marks the beginning and the end of each. History is neither chance nor a deaf fate: it is the stage of a government. And there is an echo of Moses here, who had already sung: “When the most High divided to the nations their inheritance (…) he set the bounds of the people” (Deuteronomy 32:8). The God Paul proclaims is no Athenian novelty: he is the Lord of history whom Israel already knew.
“In him we live”: a God nearer than we imagine
That they should seek the Lord, if haply they might feel after him, and find him, though he be not far from every one of us…Acts 17:27
Now Paul reveals the purpose of all this: why God made humanity from one man, why he ordered times and places: “That they should seek the Lord.” All of creation, all of history, is a call: God arranged the world so that man, looking around and within, would be led to seek him. But look at the words Paul uses for this search: “if haply they might feel after him, and find him.” The Greek verb, ψηλαφήσειαν (psēlaphḗseian), is the gesture of someone groping in the dark: a blind man’s outstretched hand, feeling blindly for a wall, a way out. It is an image of immense compassion and immense sadness at the same time. Humanity seeks God: in every people there is this hunger, these altars, this restlessness, but it seeks groping in the dark, fumbling, unable to see. The Athenians, with all their temples, were living proof of it: they groped so much that they set up an altar “to the unknown god.” The religions of the world are the blind man’s outstretched hand, which does not find the face it is looking for.
And then comes the comfort, the turn to tenderness in the middle of the sadness: “though he be not far from every one of us.” What a painful and beautiful irony. People grope in the dark for a God who is right there, within reach, closer than their own breath. The distance is not one of space, for God is not far away; the distance is one of knowledge, the blindfold over the eyes. Against the Epicureans, who exiled the gods into a distant indifference, Paul affirms a near God, involved, within reach of each one. He has not hidden himself; it is we who have our eyes shut. And notice the delicacy of “every one of us”: not a God near to peoples in general, in the abstract, but to each person, individually. That immense God whom the heaven of heavens cannot contain is, at the same time, beside every soul that gropes for him. Too far to fit in a temple; too near to hide from a heart that seeks him.
For in him we live, and move, and have our being; as certain also of your own poets have said, For we are also his offspring.Acts 17:28
And here Paul proves how near God is, with one of the most profound sentences in all of Scripture: “in him we live, and move, and have our being.” Linger over the three verbs, because they climb a ladder of intimacy. In him we live: he is the source of our life. In him we move: he sustains every movement, every heartbeat, every step. In him we have our being: existence itself depends on him at every moment. It is not that God created the world and let it loose to run on its own, as the Epicureans thought; it is that the whole creation only goes on existing because he holds it, now, this very second. We are like fish in the ocean: not only made by the water, but surrounded by it, breathing in it, unable to exist for an instant outside it. Take God out from under the universe and the universe goes dark. “In him,” ἐν αὐτῷ (en autôi), we live, just as a diver lives in the air that surrounds him. He is not far away: we are inside him, enveloped by his sustaining power with every breath the philosophers spent debating him.
And notice what Paul does next, because it is the crown of his wisdom as a communicator: he quotes their poets, and notice the plural, because there are two lines he weaves together. The first, “in him we live, and move, and have our being,” tradition attributes to Epimenides, the Cretan (the same man behind the altars “to the unknown god,” and from whom Paul quotes yet another line in Titus 1:12). The second he states right after: “as certain also of your own poets have said, For we are also his offspring.” That line, τοῦ γὰρ καὶ γένος ἐσμέν, comes from the poet Aratus, from his work Phaenomena, and also echoes a hymn to Zeus by Cleanthes, the Stoic. Paul, the Jew, had read the Greek poets, and now he uses their words to preach his truth. Notice the precision of the gesture, because there is a lesson of method in it. He does not quote Scripture, which would carry no weight with those ears; he quotes what they already accepted, and from the fragment of truth they held he builds the bridge to the full truth. The Greek poets, speaking of Zeus, had groped toward a truth without knowing it: that we depend on the divine, that we are God’s “offspring.” Paul takes this shard of light from their culture and holds it up: yes, we are God’s offspring, not of the Zeus of the myths, but of the God who made the world and does not live in temples.
And here we must read with the care our method demands, because this sentence, “For we are also his offspring,” is one of those that get twisted to say what they do not say. Notice what Paul affirms and what he does not affirm. He affirms that all of humanity, as creature, comes from God: all of us, Greeks and barbarians, are made by him, dependent on him, his “offspring” in the sense of creatures that came from his creating hand. It is the same sense in which Adam is called “the son of God” in Luke 3:38, a son by creation. But Paul is not saying that human beings are divine, sparks of god, as Stoic pantheism held; nor that they are children of God in the full sense of redemption, which the New Testament reserves for those who believe and receive “power to become the sons of God” (John 1:12). There is a universal sonship, by creation: in it we are all God’s offspring, and it is this that Paul draws on here to call the pagans back to the Creator. And there is a particular sonship, by grace, which is received by believing. To confuse the two is to make the text prove what it does not prove. Paul uses creation as a hook to call people to repentance, and it is precisely to repentance that he is about to turn.
If we are his offspring, gold cannot be god
Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, graven by art and man’s device.Acts 17:29
See how Paul springs the trap with the Greeks’ own logic. He has just quoted their poet, “we are also his offspring,” and now he turns that sentence against idolatry like a lever: “Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God”: since you yourselves say that we come from the divine, it is absurd to think “that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone.” (The Godhead of the King James is τὸ θεῖον, “the divine.”) The argument is unanswerable, and it is beautiful in its simplicity. If we, living, thinking beings who love and choose, come from God, then God must be greater than we are, not lesser. How could the Creator of a living being be a dead thing? How can what gives life be a lifeless stone? The idol is always inferior to the man who made it: it is gold that does not think, stone that does not love, metal that does not breathe, “graven by art and man’s device.” It is the creature carving something beneath itself and calling it god. Idolatry is not only wrong; it is illogical. To worship what our hands have made is to kneel before something less alive than the very knees that bend.
And notice that Paul, once again, preaches Israel without quoting Israel. The prophets had already laughed at this folly with cutting sarcasm. Isaiah described the man who cuts down a tree, uses half the wood to warm himself and bake his bread, and “the residue thereof he maketh a god, even his graven image: he falleth down unto it, and worshippeth it” (Isaiah 44:15–17): half the trunk becomes firewood, the other half becomes a divinity. The psalmist sang of idols: “They have mouths, but they speak not: eyes have they, but they see not (…) neither speak they through their throat” (Psalm 115:5–7). Jeremiah compared them to a scarecrow in a cucumber field (so most read the Hebrew; the King James has “upright as the palm tree”) and said that “they must needs be borne, because they cannot go” (Jeremiah 10:5), a god that has to be carried on the backs of those who worship it. Paul distills all this prophetic mockery into one philosopher’s sentence, and serves it to the philosophers: the living God does not look like dead metal. The irony is perfect: the highest culture in the world bowed down before puppets that the prophets of a “barbarian” people had unmasked a thousand years earlier.
The times of ignorance are over: the command that reaches everyone
And the times of this ignorance God winked at; but now commandeth all men every where to repent…Acts 17:30
Here the tone changes, and changes decisively, from explanation to summons. Until now Paul has described who God is; now he says what God requires. “The times of this ignorance God winked at”: in the English of the King James, he overlooked them, he “passed over” the ages in which the peoples groped for him in the dark. God, in his patience, tolerated that long period of darkness in which the nations did not know him. But (and this “but” is a watershed in history) something changed. The coming of Christ divided time in two: there was the age of ignorance, which God bore with, and there is now the age of light, in which ignorance no longer has an excuse, because the unknown God has made himself known. The hook of the “unknown god” closes here: he is no longer unknown; he has been proclaimed; and with knowledge comes responsibility.
And look at the reach of the command, because no word in it is small. “But now”: no longer tomorrow, not in some distant age; now, in this time, in this hour on the Areopagus. “All men”: not only Israel, not only those who were already seeking; all, without exception of race or culture. “Every where”: not only in Jerusalem, not only in the temple; in Athens, in the agora, in every corner of the earth. And what does God command of all, everywhere, now? “To repent.” The word is μετανοεῖν (metanoeîn), which means to change one’s mind, to turn around, a radical change of direction, leaving the idols and turning to the living God. Notice the force of this, said to philosophers who considered themselves the wise men of the world: God does not ask them to debate the proposal, nor to find it interesting, nor to add it to their collection of ideas. He commands them to repent. The gospel does not arrive at the Areopagus as a thesis to be considered; it arrives as a commandment to be obeyed. And the reason for this absolute urgency comes in the next sentence, the gravest of the whole speech.
One day, one man, one proof: the judgment guaranteed by the resurrection
Because he hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world in righteousness by that man whom he hath ordained; whereof he hath given assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead.Acts 17:31
This is the reason for urgent repentance, and it falls on the Areopagus like thunder: there is a judgment scheduled. “He hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world in righteousness.” God has set a date (it already exists on heaven’s calendar) on which he will judge “the world,” τὴν οἰκουμένην, the whole inhabited world, all people of all times and places. Against the Epicureans, who denied any judgment after death (to die was to dissolve and be gone), Paul drives the point home: there is a reckoning to come, universal and inescapable. And this judgment will be “in righteousness,” ἐν δικαιοσύνῃ: not the arbitrary whim of the gods of Olympus, who punished out of envy or mood, but a perfectly just judgment, in which nothing will be crooked. The date exists, but it is locked away: what Jesus told us to read were the signs of the season, never the day. That is why repentance is urgent: not because God is a tyrant eager to condemn, but because there is a real date before which each one will appear, and before it one must turn around.
And now Paul says who will be the judge, and we must listen with full attention, because the wording is strikingly precise: God will judge “by that man whom he hath ordained.” Stop at each word. The judge of the world will be a man: ἀνήρ (anḗr), a man, a human being. And this man was ordained by God for this role: ὥρισεν (hṓrisen), “designated,” “named,” “appointed.” Note carefully the design Paul himself draws, which is the key to our reading: there is God, who sets the day and appoints the judge; and there is the appointed man, by whom, ἐν ἀνδρὶ, the judgment will take place. One commissions; the other is commissioned. One appoints; the other is appointed. The judgment is God’s, exercised through the man he chose and authorized for it. This is no secondary detail: it is the way the apostle himself, at the height of his speech, defines the relationship between God and the one through whom God will judge the world, Jesus.
And how can we know that this man really is the appointed judge? What guarantee has God given that this is not just one more religious claim among many? Paul points to the proof, and it is the proof that changes everything: “whereof he hath given assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead.” The word for “assurance” is πίστιν (pístin), here in the sense of guarantee, public proof, pledge. The resurrection is God’s signature under that man’s identity. God could have simply declared, “This is the judge,” and it would have been word against word. Instead, he raised the man from the dead, in front of witnesses, and so proved, before everyone, that this man is who he says he is. The resurrection is not only the happy ending of Jesus’ story; it is the Judge’s public credential, the evidence God extended “unto all men,” including those Greeks, that the appointed day is real and the appointed man is true. And it was precisely at this word, resurrection, that the speech broke off, as we will see. But before hearing the reaction, we must linger over what Paul has just said about God, because the heart of everything is here.
The one God, the Father, and the man he appointed
It is worth setting everything else aside and lingering here, because this Areopagus speech contains the clearest statement of the doctrine of God in the whole Book of Acts, and it must be read exactly as Paul formulated it, without adding or taking away. When an apostle presents God to people who have never heard of him, assuming nothing, from scratch, what does he say? It is at that moment, stripped of any prior assumption on the listener’s part, that the most basic structure of the faith appears bare. And what appears is so clear that it leaves no room for doubt: one God, the Creator of all things; and a man, appointed by that God, through whom he will judge the world.
First gather what Paul says about God in this speech, collecting the features he laid down one by one. This God “made the world and all things therein” (v. 24): he is the one Creator, the source of all things. He is “Lord of heaven and earth” (v. 24), the absolute sovereign. He is not “worshipped with men’s hands, as though he needed any thing” (v. 25): he is self-sufficient, dependent on nothing and no one. He “giveth to all life, and breath, and all things” (v. 25): he is the source of all being. He “hath made of one blood all nations of men” (v. 26): he is the origin of humanity. He “hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds” (v. 26): he is the Lord of history. “In him we live, and move, and have our being” (v. 28): he is the one in whom all things are held together. This is the portrait of God that Paul paints for Athens: one, uncaused, Creator, Sustainer, Sovereign, source of all that exists. There is no division here, no parts, no second source beside him. There is God, and everything else is his creature and his gift.
Now gather what Paul says about the judge, and notice the careful distance he keeps. The judge is “that man” (v. 31), a human being. He is not called God here; he is called man, ἀνήρ. And this man is the one God “hath ordained” (v. 31), whom God designated, named, assigned to the role of judge. And his authority is received: the judgment is God’s, exercised “by” the man he chose. Notice, with the care our method demands, what Paul does not do. He does not say that the judge is a second divine person co-equal with the Creator. He does not say that God and the judge are the same person. He clearly maintains the distinction and the order: God appoints; this man is appointed. God judges; this man is the one through whom God judges. The initiative, the authority, the determination all come from God; the appointed man receives them and exercises them in the name of the one who sent him.
And this design (God, the only source, acting through a man whom he exalted and authorized) is not a peculiarity of the Athens sermon. It is the backbone of apostolic preaching from the first day. Listen to Peter at Pentecost, at the very opening of Acts: “Jesus of Nazareth, a man approved of God among you by miracles (…) Him, being delivered (…) Whom God hath raised up” (Acts 2:22–24). And later, the climax of the same sermon: “God hath made that same Jesus, whom ye have crucified, both Lord and Christ” (Acts 2:36). Stop at this sentence, because it is the twin sister of what Paul says on the Areopagus. It is not that Jesus was Lord and Christ by a nature he possessed independently; it is that God made him Lord and Christ: the dignity is conferred, bestowed by the Father on the man he raised and exalted. The same structure as in Athens: a God who makes, and a man who is made Lord by him.
Jesus himself spoke of himself in this same direction, and it is good to hear him, so that our reading is not imposed from outside but gathered from the text. On judgment, exactly the subject of the Areopagus, Jesus said: “the Father judgeth no man, but hath committed all judgment unto the Son (…) because he is the Son of man” (John 5:22, 27). Notice the verb: the Father committed judgment to the Son; the authority to judge is received from the Father, exactly as Paul will say that God will judge “by that man whom he hath ordained.” And Jesus was even more explicit about the origin of this authority: “The Son can do nothing of himself, but what he seeth the Father do” (John 5:19); “I can of mine own self do nothing (…) because I seek not mine own will, but the will of the Father which hath sent me” (John 5:30). Everything the Son has and does, he receives and does in the name of the Father who sent him. And the confession that seals this, spoken by Jesus himself on the eve of the cross: “my Father is greater than I” (John 14:28). The one sent is not greater than the one who sent him; the one appointed is not greater than the one who appointed him.
And it is the same Paul of the Areopagus who, writing to the churches, maintains this order with a consistency that cannot be ignored. To the Corinthians he draws the whole hierarchy in one sentence: “the head of every man is Christ (…) and the head of Christ is God” (1 Corinthians 11:3): above Christ is God, as above man is Christ. Again to the Corinthians, about the end of all things: when everything has been subjected to him, “then shall the Son also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, that God may be all in all” (1 Corinthians 15:28): the Son, at the end, subject to the Father, so that God may be all. And the key confession, the one that echoes Israel’s Shema with deliberate precision: “there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things (…) and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things” (1 Corinthians 8:6). Listen to the structure: one God, and that God is identified, in so many words, as the Father; and one Lord, Jesus Christ, the one through whom the Father makes and remakes all things. It is exactly the design of the Areopagus, put as a formula: the Father is the source (of whom are all things); the Son is the mediator (by whom). The same preposition we saw in Athens: God judges “by that man whom he hath ordained.”
Now tie the thread together, because this is where the Athens speech sheds light on our whole reading. When Paul presents God from scratch, to people who had never heard of him, what emerges is not a God divided into three equals, but one God (the Father, the Creator, the uncaused source of all things, the one in whom we live and have our being) and, beside him, distinct from him and appointed by him, the man through whom he will judge the world, the same man he raised as public proof. This man’s dignity is very high: he is the Judge of all the living, nothing less, but it is a dignity that is received, bestowed, conferred by the Father. He judges because he was appointed to judge; he reigns because he was made Lord; he was exalted because the Father exalted him. Never the source; always the one who receives from the source.
And it is good to say frankly what the text does not authorize us to affirm, so that our reading may come from the Bible and not from outside it. The Areopagus speech knows nothing of a second divine person, co-eternal and co-equal. There is no “God the Son” here indistinct from “God the Father”; there is God, the Father, and the man he appointed. This does not reduce the Son to a mere creature like the others: the New Testament confesses him as the Logos through whom all things were made (1 Corinthians 8:6, “by whom are all things”), the beloved Son, begotten of the Father, exalted above every name. But it always confesses him as from the Father, through the Father, for the glory of the Father: derived, not the source; sent, not the sender; appointed, not the one who appoints. The “one God” to whom Paul calls Athens back, the one of whom the poets groped a shadow, the one who does not live in temples and gives us breath, is the Father. And the way back to him passes through a man: the one whom the Father raised and appointed, and before whom, on a day already fixed, we will all give account. Paul did not preach two gods to the Athenians; they already had far too many gods. He preached the only one, and the man through whom the only God made himself known and will judge.
They mocked, they put it off, they believed: what the truth does to a heart
And when they heard of the resurrection of the dead, some mocked: and others said, We will hear thee again of this matter.Acts 17:32
Notice exactly where the speech breaks off, because the breaking point reveals everything. Paul preached the Creator, and the philosophers listened. He preached the God who sustains and is near, and quoted their poets, and they followed along. He preached against idols, and the logic was sound. But the instant he said “the resurrection of the dead,” the audience split. That is where it stuck. For the cultured Greek, the idea was simply unthinkable. Greek philosophy despised the body: it saw it as the prison of the soul, a shell from which death finally frees the spirit. Salvation, for them, was the soul escaping the body. And then a Jew comes along to say that God raised a body from death, and, worse, that he will do the same with everyone, at a judgment. For the Athenian, raising a corpse was not good news: it was a grotesque step backward, returning the soul to the prison it had escaped. The cross was already folly; the resurrection was the height of absurdity.
And look at the first two reactions, because they portray two ways of running from the truth without facing it. Some “mocked”: ἐχλεύαζον (echleúazon), they laughed scornfully, they jeered. It is the reaction of wounded pride: when an argument is uncomfortable and cannot be refuted, you laugh at it. Laughter becomes a wall; mockery spares one the trouble of thinking. Others were more polite, and for that very reason more dangerous: “We will hear thee again of this matter.” They did not mock; they postponed. And postponement is the subtlest of refusals, because it looks like openness. They did not say “no”; they said “later.” But “later,” in the face of God’s command for now, is a “no” disguised as courtesy. Paul had said that God commands people to repent now; they answered, “Some other time.” And, from what Luke records, that other time, for most of them, never came. Athenian curiosity, always chasing the next novelty, swallowed this one too: it listened, found it interesting, filed it away and went hunting for another. Putting off the truth is the elegant way of losing it.
So Paul departed from among them. Howbeit certain men clave unto him, and believed: among the which was Dionysius the Areopagite, and a woman named Damaris, and others with them.Acts 17:33–34
And then, in the middle of the mockery and the postponement, the third reaction shines, small but real: “certain men clave unto him, and believed.” It was not a crowd as in Berea, nor a riot as in Thessalonica. It was “certain men.” And it is honest to face this: Athens was, in numbers, the smallest harvest of the journey. Some have read this speech as a relative failure: so few believed, and Luke does not mention a church planted there as in the other cities. But look carefully at what those few mean, because grace does not count the way the world counts. A heart that surrenders to the living God, snatched from the middle of the most learned mockery in the world, is no small number in heaven’s eyes. And the names Luke makes a point of preserving say a great deal.
Hold on to the two names, because they are not there by chance. First, “Dionysius the Areopagite,” that is, a member of the Areopagus itself, one of the judges of that supreme council, one of the most respected and learned men in Athens. From the very heart of the institution that had listened to Paul with cold curiosity, one man was converted. The wisdom of Athens mocked through the mouth of the majority, but knelt through the soul of one of its highest. Second, “a woman named Damaris.” Luke preserves her name, which is significant, because in a city where respectable women rarely moved in the public sphere of speeches, a woman heard, believed and had her name recorded forever. A judge from the elite and a woman: in Athens the gospel did not gather a crowd, but it did what it always does: it reached the high and the lowly, and crossed the boundaries the city considered impassable. “And others with them”: names that Luke did not record, but heaven did. The harvest was small in the eyes of men and precious in the eyes of God.
The stone every speech stumbles on: why the resurrection divides
Before closing the chapter, it is worth gathering up why it was that word, resurrection, that split the Areopagus down the middle, because it was no accident, and the lesson crosses the centuries to reach us. It was not the Creator, nor judgment in the abstract, nor the critique of idols that made the Greeks laugh. It was the resurrection of the body. And this is no detail of ancient history: it is the point at which, even today, the Christian faith parts ways with every religion and every philosophy the world is capable of producing on its own.
Understand why this stone cannot be replaced. Paul did not place it at the end of the speech by chance, nor could he remove it to please his hearers. The resurrection is the gospel; take it away and nothing is left. It is what proves that the appointed man really is the Judge; it is by it that God “hath given assurance unto all men” (Acts 17:31). Paul himself would write, years later, to the church in Corinth, another Greek city with the same difficulty: “if Christ be not risen, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain (…) ye are yet in your sins” (1 Corinthians 15:14, 17). He could not negotiate this point on the Areopagus, because negotiating it would empty everything. Better to lose the audience than to lose the gospel. And he lost a good part of the audience, but kept the gospel whole, and some believed it whole. Preaching that cuts out the resurrection to suit the hearer’s taste may fill rooms, but it no longer has anything to preach.
And it is good to see that this stone has deep roots in the hope of Israel, even though Athens did not know it. The resurrection of the body was not a Christian invention; it was the hope that already beat in the Scriptures and in the heart of God’s people. Daniel had announced it: “many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame” (Daniel 12:2). Isaiah had sung: “Thy dead men shall live, together with my dead body shall they arise” (Isaiah 26:19). Job, in the depths of his pain, had confessed: “though after my skin worms destroy this body, yet in my flesh shall I see God” (Job 19:26). And the Pharisees, in Jesus’ day, firmly held this faith against the Sadducees, who denied it. The rabbinic tradition made the resurrection of the dead, תְּחִיַּת הַמֵּתִים (techiyat hametim), one of the non-negotiable pillars of the faith; Maimonides included it among his thirteen fundamental principles, and the tradition of the Mishnah goes as far as declaring that whoever denies that the resurrection of the dead is found in the Torah has no share in the world to come (Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1). Here, once again, the faith of Israel and the Christian faith join hands: against the Greek contempt for the body, both affirm that the body matters, that God made it, that God will raise it. What Hellenism considered absurd, revelation has always held as hope.
And where the two readings differ (honestly, without erasing the convergence) is in the pledge. For the rabbinic tradition, the resurrection of the dead is a future hope, guaranteed by God’s faithfulness to the covenant. For the gospel, that future hope already has an advance proof in history: one man has already risen, and his resurrection is the firstfruits, the first fruit that guarantees the harvest. “now is Christ risen from the dead, and become the firstfruits of them that slept” (1 Corinthians 15:20). The hope of Israel pointed to a day; the gospel announces that this day has already cast its first light, in an empty tomb at the gates of Jerusalem. It is the same hope, with a pledge already paid in the middle of time. And that is why Paul could preach it not as theory, but as attested fact: not “I believe there will be a resurrection,” but “he hath given assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him.”
Gather up, then, what this whole chapter leaves in our hands, from the three cities to the Areopagus. The same word ran through Thessalonica, Berea and Athens, and met the jealousy that persecutes, the heart that examines and believes, and the curiosity that listens and postpones. Three soils, three harvests. And at the end of it all, in the heart of Athens, the gospel did not retreat one step from its scandal: it preached one God, the Father, against a whole pantheon; it preached repentance now, against the laziness of “later”; and it preached the resurrection, against the wisdom of the entire Greek world. And from Athens, with no church planted and almost in silence, Paul goes down alone to the city with the worst reputation in Greece, where he would hear from God the sentence that would sustain eighteen months of work: “I have much people in this city”. It cost him the audience, but it won Dionysius, it won Damaris, it won “others” whose names heaven knows by heart. And it left, planted in the middle of the most cultured city on earth, the question that still divides every heart that hears it: before the God who does not live in temples, who gives us breath, and before the man he raised and appointed as judge, will you mock, postpone, or believe?
Notes
1. The Via Egnatia was the Roman road built c. 146–120 BC by Gnaeus Egnatius, proconsul of Macedonia, who gave it his name. An eastern extension of the Via Appia, it linked the Adriatic (Dyrrachium and Apollonia, in present-day Albania) to Byzantium, the future Constantinople (today Istanbul), crossing Macedonia and Thrace for about 1,100 km. It passed through Philippi, Amphipolis, Apollonia and Thessalonica, so the itinerary of Acts 17:1 follows exactly this axis. Stretches of the ancient paving still survive near Philippi and Kavala, and the same route is followed today by the Greek motorway Egnatia Odos (Εγνατία Οδός), completed in 2009.
2. The Greek term politárchēs (πολιτάρχης) does not appear in any other work of classical Greek literature, which led critics to suspect an error. Confirmation came from epigraphy: the most famous witness is the inscription of the Vardar Gate, in Thessalonica, carved on a Roman arch over the Via Egnatia and dated to the second century AD. The gate was demolished in 1876, but the block was preserved and is now in the British Museum (object 1877,0511.1), where it lists six politarchs, along with the city’s treasurer (tamías) and gymnasiarch. The title has now been identified in dozens of inscriptions, most of them from Macedonia and about half from Thessalonica itself, attesting exactly the usage Luke makes in Acts 17:6, 8. See C. E. Fant and M. G. Reddish, Lost Treasures of the Bible (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008), pp. 366–370; and the British Museum record, object 1877,0511.1.
3. Midrash (from the Hebrew darash, “to search out, to interpret”): the genre of Jewish rabbinic interpretation that probes the meaning of the Hebrew Scriptures, gathered in collections from the first centuries of the Christian era. The “Midrash on Genesis” is Bereshit Rabbah, one of these collections.
4. Rashi: an acronym for Rabbi Shlomo Yitzhaki (1040–1105), of Troyes, in France, author of the most influential Jewish commentary on the Hebrew Bible and the Talmud, famous for its concision. (The Talmud is the great compilation of the legal and interpretive tradition of rabbinic Judaism.)
5. The saying goes back to Petronius (Satyricon 17), who said of his own region that “there are so many gods that it is easier to meet one than it is to find a man” (tr. W. C. Firebaugh). The city’s devotion and its profusion of images are attested by ancient authors such as Pausanias, for whom the Athenians are “far more devoted to religion than other men” (Description of Greece I.24.3, tr. W. H. S. Jones), and Livy, who counts among the sights of Athens “the statues of gods and men” (45.27, tr. W. A. McDevitte).
6. The parentheses here are editorial punctuation, not a sign of textual doubt: they only mark an aside by the narrator. The verse stands in full in the Greek text. Absence or doubt in the manuscripts is usually marked with square brackets [ ] and a note, as in John 7:53–8:11 or Mark 16:9–20, never with parentheses. It is worth remembering that the original manuscripts had no punctuation at all, no spaces between words and no verse numbers: all of that was added later to help the reader.
7. Diogenes Laertius (a Greek biographer of the third century AD, whose Lives of the Philosophers is the main ancient source on the Greek thinkers), Lives I.110, which speaks of “nameless” altars and of sacrifice “to the appropriate god” of the place, not literally “to the unknown god.” Pausanias speaks of altars “of the gods named Unknown” (Description of Greece I.1.4, tr. W. H. S. Jones), in the plural, and so does Philostratus (Life of Apollonius VI.3). The synthesis that fuses the two pieces of evidence into a single story was popularized by Don Richardson in Eternity in Their Hearts.
8. “Barbarian,” for a Greek, was anyone who did not speak Greek: the word imitated the “bar-bar” of foreign speech, and the world was divided into Hellenes and barbarians (see Romans 1:14). The Scythians were nomadic peoples of the steppes north of the Black Sea, regarded by Greeks and Romans as the very model of the savage barbarian; Paul takes them as the limit case in Colossians 3:11 (“Where there is neither Greek nor Jew (…) Barbarian, Scythian, bond nor free: but Christ is all, and in all”).