Yesterday and today, Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (the STF) has been deciding whether running the jogo do bicho (the “animal game,” an illegal numbers lottery that is a fixture of Brazilian street life), bingo and slot machines is still a crime in Brazil. The case reached the Court through a shopkeeper from Rio Grande do Sul who was acquitted for keeping three slot machines in his place of business. The technical question is whether article 50 of the Criminal Misdemeanors Act, signed by Getúlio Vargas (Brazil’s president at the time) in 1941, survived the Constitution of 1988. The case has been given general repercussion (its ruling binds every similar case), Justice Luiz Fux is the rapporteur, and the thesis that comes out of it will decide 2,728 stalled cases in courts at every level across the country.
Fux signaled a vote to uphold the ban. He said something worth keeping: there is no way to speak of free enterprise when the subject is gambling, because the two concepts are opposed. And he passed the ball back to Congress: if it is going to change, let the legislature change it.
But that is not the sentence I want to deal with. I want to deal with another one, spoken from the lectern by someone arguing the opposite side.
The sentence spoken before the Court that the church needed to hear
Speaking for the National Association of Mayors and Deputy Mayors, the lawyer Alessandra Jirardi raised the most uncomfortable argument of the whole session: the State itself runs lotteries. If the State sells the Mega-Sena (Brazil’s national lottery) on the street corner, by what authority does it say that the slot machine offends public morality? This is not cheap rhetoric. It is a real problem, and Brazil built it in three acts, each of them defensible on its own.
In 2020, the STF ruled on ADPFs 492 and 493 and ADI 49861 and decided, unanimously, that the federal government has the monopoly to legislate on lotteries but not the exclusive right to run them. The lottery became a public service, and the states were authorized to enter the business. In 2023, Congress passed Law 14,790, legalizing and taxing the bets (as Brazilians call the online sports-betting and casino sites). And now, in 2026, the Supreme Court is discussing whether the shopkeeper’s slot machine is still a criminal misdemeanor.
Add the three together: the Brazilian State runs gambling, licenses it, taxes it, and still sends people to jail for it. This is not the hypocrisy of one official. It is structural incoherence. And before we point the finger, we would do well to look at our own church hall: how many churches condemn the betting sites on Sunday morning and raffle off a gift basket on Wednesday night to fix the roof?
The problem is that our answer is usually “I think”
The question is embarrassing for a reason that comes before it: we have never grounded our own answer. Ask ten Christians whether playing the Mega-Sena is a sin. You will hear ten answers and no grounds. Some will say it is, because “it’s worldly.” Others will say it is not, because “there’s nothing in the Bible about it.” A third will say it depends on the heart, which is true and is not an answer, because everything depends on the heart, and that settles no case at all.
That is the state of the question in the Brazilian church: strong opinion, weak foundation. And the result is predictable. When the Christian needs to take a position on a subject the whole country is discussing, he has nothing to say beyond what he has heard said.
That is not how the Bible is read. The Bereans, who searched the Scriptures daily to see whether those things were so, checked even the apostle. The honor of this site’s name comes from there. So let us do what they would do: open the text, read what is written, read also what is not written, and only then conclude.
I will tell you ahead of time that the road has a surprise right at the entrance.
Is gambling a sin? The first surprise: there is no “thou shalt not bet”
There is no prohibition of gambling in the Torah. There is none in the Ten Commandments. There is none in the teaching of Jesus. And there is an even harder fact, one that practically no one mentions from the pulpit: gambling does not appear in any list of vices in the New Testament.2
Check them one by one: Romans 1:29–31, 1 Corinthians 6:9–10, Galatians 5:19–21, Ephesians 5:3–5, Colossians 3:5–8, 1 Timothy 1:9–10, Revelation 21:8 and 22:15. They are long, specific lists that name everything from murder to slander. None of them mentions gambling.
If sin is the transgression of the law, as John defines it:
Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law.1 John 3:4
Then the wager in itself is not a sin, because no formal law of God is being transgressed. This needs to be said plainly, and it is exactly what the prohibitionists avoid saying.
Technically, then, games of chance fall into a category that theology baptized with a difficult word: adiaphora, that is, an indifferent thing, which God neither commanded nor forbade. And I am not the one saying it. The Wisconsin Synod (WELS, a North American Lutheran denomination of strictly confessional stripe, nothing lax in matters of ethics) recognizes that gambling is not specifically mentioned in the Bible and for that reason falls into this category, even though it does not recommend it.
And the Westminster Confession (a confession of faith drawn up in 1646, the doctrinal standard of Presbyterian and Reformed churches to this day) is severe with those who invent commandments: “God alone is Lord of the conscience, and hath left it free from the doctrines and commandments of men, which are in any thing contrary to His Word; or beside it, if matters of faith or worship.”3
The word for “dice playing” is in the New Testament, and it is used only once
If there is no commandment, the next question is what Scripture says on the few occasions the subject brushes against it. Here comes a detail that cuts both ways, and for that very reason it is honest.
The Greek word for dice playing is κυβεία (kubeia), derived from κύβος, the cube, the die. It appears in the New Testament. Only once, in Ephesians 4:14, when Paul speaks of those who are carried about with every wind of doctrine “by the sleight of men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to deceive.” The word behind “sleight” is kubeia.
And there it does not mean a game. It means cheating. The word migrated from “dice playing” to “fraud” because the players cheated so much that the name of the game became the name of the con. The picture behind it is the sleight-of-hand man who hides a second pair of dice in his palm.4
For those who argue for severity: in the first century, gambling was so notoriously fraudulent that Paul could use it as a metaphor for deceit without needing to explain the figure. For those who argue for liberty: the Holy Spirit had the word at hand and did not use it a single time to forbid the practice.
Keep both readings. Both are true, and neither of them closes the question.
So is the Bible silent? It speaks of the lot almost seventy times
Here is the point that changes the conversation. Scripture does not speak of gambling, but it speaks of the lot all the time, and not always in the same way. There are almost seventy occurrences, and they fall into four groups that hardly anyone separates.
First group: the lot in worship, ordained by God. The two goats of the Day of Atonement are assigned by lot, and the lot decides which one dies (Leviticus 16:8). The Urim and the Thummim were kept in the high priest’s breastplate (Exodus 28:30). The courses of priests, singers and porters were distributed by lot (1 Chronicles 24–26). And, already in the New Testament, Zacharias was chosen by lot to burn incense on the night the angel appeared to him (Luke 1:9).
Second group: the dividing of the inheritance. The whole promised land was divided by lot (Numbers 26:55; Joshua 14–19). The fulfillment of the promise to Abraham was distributed by a method that, seen from outside, is identical to a drawing.
Third group: the lot that uncovers and decides. Achan was singled out by lot (Joshua 7:14–18). Saul was chosen king by lot (1 Samuel 10:20–21). The sailors found Jonah out by lot (Jonah 1:7). And Matthias was added to the eleven by lot (Acts 1:26).
Fourth group, and no one cites this one: the lot in the hands of the wicked. Haman cast Pur to choose the day for exterminating the Jews, and the feast of Purim bears the name of that lot (Esther 3:7; 9:24–26). The king of Babylon shook arrows and looked in the liver to decide which city to begin with (Ezekiel 21:21). Enemies cast lots over God’s people, dividing captives as spoil (Joel 3:3; Nahum 3:10). And the soldiers cast lots for Christ’s coat (John 19:23–24).
Notice what this means. The same lot Joshua used, Haman used. The instrument neither sanctifies nor condemns. Who uses it, and for what, is what decides.
And some care is needed in reading Jonah, which is often misused: the ones casting lots there are pagan sailors, each crying to his own god. God honors their lot in the same way he had already sent the wind and would later prepare the fish, the gourd and the worm. The text does not teach a method of consultation. It teaches that God governs even the pagan’s superstition in order to reach the runaway prophet. The text tells what happened; it does not tell anyone to do the same, and that difference alone settles half the quarrels about biblical ethics. Consulting the lot to know what to do is another matter, and Scripture deals with it in nine distinct words in Deuteronomy 18.
What Proverbs 16:33 says, and what people make it say
The lot is cast into the lap; but the whole disposing thereof is of the LORD.Proverbs 16:33
Among the almost seventy occurrences, this is the one that became the standard verse of the debate. And it is cited by both sides, without either of them reading it properly. It is not a permission for gambling, and it is not a prohibition. It is an affirmation of sovereignty. The proverb says that there is no such thing as chance: what seems random to man is under government. That holds for the die, and it holds equally for the rain, for the drawing of the work roster and for the day you were born.
The verse describes how God governs; it does not prescribe a method for man to use. Whoever uses it to authorize betting is making the text say what it does not say. And so is whoever uses it to condemn, arguing that the gambler “forces God’s hand.”
The verse almost no one uses, and the best argument of the two
The lot causeth contentions to cease, and parteth between the mighty.Proverbs 18:18
If Proverbs 16:33 settles nothing, two chapters further on there is a proverb that settles a great deal, and it is very rare to see it cited in this debate. The setting is a courtroom: a way of breaking the deadlock in stalled disputes between influential people, precisely so that the stronger one does not win by sheer weight. In other words: the lot of Proverbs 18:18 exists to protect the weak from the strong.
Samson bet thirty changes of garments, and that is not why God judged him
Before leaving the Old Testament, the concrete case is still missing, the one that always comes up when the discussion comes down from theory to the table. “So can I bet a lunch with a friend?” The question is fair, and the Bible has an identical case. At the wedding feast, Samson put a riddle to thirty Philistines and made a formal bet: thirty linen shirts and thirty changes of garments, with a deadline of seven days (Judges 14:12–19). A high stake. A public bet. Now notice what the narrative does and what it does not do. It condemns the woman’s pressure, the companions’ treachery, the anger and the slaughter that come afterward. There is not a word of censure for the bet itself. When God judges Samson (and he does judge him), it is not for what he staked on the riddle.
Add to this that the queen of Sheba traveled to prove Solomon with “hard questions,” and that riddles with a prize were a common form of social life in that world. Scripture knows the friendly bet and does not forbid it.
So the honest answer is this: two friends, a stake that neither of them will miss, no house making a profit, no third party harmed, no mastery over anyone’s heart, and there is no biblical basis for calling it a sin. To call it one would be adding to the Word.
But hold on to that conclusion, because it has a price that almost no one wants to pay. I will come back to it at the end.
Seventeen centuries of the church saying no
Once what Scripture says has been laid out, it remains to hear those who read it before us, and there the tone changes completely. And do not begin with the treatises; begin with the gesture: the first Christian generation, in Ephesus, brought their own books of lots and spells out into the street and burned them, adding up the loss out loud. Let no one say the church was silent. It was very harsh, and from very early on. The Apostolic Canons (a collection of 85 rules of church discipline compiled in Syria around the fourth century, among the oldest in the canonical corpus and received in the East as the law of the Church) forbid gambling to clergy and laity alike: “If a bishop or presbyter, or deacon, is addicted to dice or drinking, let him either give it over, or be deposed,” and the next canon extends excommunication to the layman. The Council of Elvira, in Spain, around the year 305 (the oldest council whose acts have come down to us complete, gathered while the Church was still persecuted), determined in canon 79 that a believer caught gambling for money should be excluded from communion, and readmitted after a year if he had amended his ways. The Quinisext Council, gathered in Trullo in 692 (so called because it completed the fifth and sixth ecumenical councils, which had dealt only with doctrine and not with discipline), repeated the prohibition in canon 50, and that canon is still in force in Orthodoxy today.5 The Fourth Lateran Council, in 1215 (the largest council of the medieval West, convened by Innocent III, which set much of the discipline of the Latin Church), forbade clerics to play games of chance or even to be present at them, and the decree entered canon law.
There were whole treatises. The De Aleatoribus, “On Dice Players,” written between 180 and 280, is the longest anti-gambling work of the first three Christian centuries.6 Tertullian condemned gambling in the De Spectaculis7; Cyprian of Carthage listed “prodigality in gambling” among the grave vices.8
Rome opened the door, and left four locks that the betting sites cannot get past
That consensus went through more than a millennium without a crack. The first to loosen it was, of all places, Rome. The Catholic Church is today the most permissive of the historic traditions on this point, and it is necessary to be fair in setting out its position. The Catechism, in paragraph 2413, says that games of chance and wagers “are not in themselves contrary to justice”, becoming morally unacceptable when they deprive a person of what is necessary for himself and his own. And it adds that the passion for gambling risks becoming an enslavement.
It is not evil by nature, then; what makes it evil is the circumstances. But the Catholic moral tradition set four conditions for gambling to be licit: legitimate ownership of what is staked, freedom of action without coercion, absence of fraud and (this is the one that matters) equality between the parties, that is, that both sides run the same risk.9
Stop at the fourth. In a state lottery, in a slot machine or on a betting site, equality between the parties does not exist. The house operates with a permanent, structural mathematical advantage. It cannot lose in the aggregate; that is how the business sustains itself.
In other words: by the classic Catholic criterion itself, modern commercial gambling already fails the test. And it is worth recording that the National Conference of Bishops of Brazil (CNBB) has taken a position against gambling for more than four decades, citing the moral, social and family harm.
“What is gambling but covetousness in action?”
On the Protestant side, the formulation that caught on did not come from a council or a confession: it came from a pulpit. On March 1, 1891, at the Metropolitan Tabernacle, Charles Spurgeon10 was preaching on Romans 8:3–4 when he made a passing remark that became the most quoted summary of the subject. A learned prelate had declared that he could find no commandment against gambling. Spurgeon answered: “Where were his eyes? Is it not plainly written, ‘Thou shalt not covet’? What is gambling but covetousness in action?”11
It is a brilliant answer, and we need to understand exactly what it does. Spurgeon did not find a commandment against gambling. He did something else: he showed that the absence of a specific commandment does not put the conduct beyond the reach of the moral law, because the tenth commandment reaches desire, not only the act. And the desire to gain without producing, to receive without working, for the other person’s money to pass into my pocket without my giving him anything in return: that desire has a name in Scripture, and the name is covetousness.
The numbers, and they are not small
Up to here the argument has been biblical and historical. The data come in now as what they are: supporting evidence. They do not decide the question; they confirm the diagnosis.
In Brazil, the technical study by the Central Bank found that about 24 million people made at least one transfer via Pix (Brazil’s instant payment system) to betting companies, and that, in August 2024, the equivalent of 21% of everything Bolsa Família paid out that month (Bolsa Família is the federal cash-transfer program for poor families) was spent on gambling at the betting sites. The average was R$ 100 per person: this is not the big gambler; it is the volume of small people. Seventy percent were heads of household.
The Third National Survey on Alcohol and Drugs, by Unifesp with Senad,12 is the Brazilian clinical data: 28 million people bet in the last twelve months, 10.9 million show at-risk or problem behavior and about 1.4 million already meet the clinical criteria for Gambling Disorder. Among bettors aged 14 to 17, 55.2% are in the risk zone, against 37.7% of adults. And those who earn less than one minimum wage are three times more at risk. The ones most harmed are the neediest.
A study by the Institute for Health Policy Studies with Umane13 calculated that betting costs the country R$ 38.8 billion a year, with R$ 17 billion in additional deaths by suicide and R$ 10.4 billion in loss of quality of life from depression. Almost 79% of the cost is in health. Meanwhile, the indebtedness of Brazilian families hit the record of the historical series, which began in 2005.
Worldwide, the gambling Commission of the journal The Lancet Public Health, published in 2024, estimated that, among adolescents who use online casinos, the risk of developing gambling disorder is 26.4%. One in four.
And there is a change in official classification that almost no one knows about. In 2013, the DSM-514 stopped classifying pathological gambling among the impulse-control disorders and moved it to the chapter on substance-related and addictive disorders. It was the first behavioral addiction that psychiatry recognized as a true addiction, that is, dependence without a chemical substance. The World Health Organization’s ICD-11 followed the same path.15
Look at the diagnostic criteria: the need to gamble with increasing amounts of money to get the same excitement, and restlessness or irritability when trying to stop. Needing a bigger dose to feel the same thing, and feeling ill when you stop: these are the two classic marks of alcoholism. The comparison with drink was not rhetoric: it is the recognized clinical structure. The difference is that here there is no molecule. The agent is the behavior itself.
And the disorder rarely comes alone: 82.2% of people with Gambling Disorder have some other mental disorder. Reviews that bring together dozens of studies find a raised risk of suicidal ideation and suicide attempts, and more than a third of problem gamblers report involvement in physical intimate partner violence, as victim or as perpetrator.
A note of intellectual honesty, which I make on purpose: most of these studies are a snapshot of one moment, not a follow-up of the same people over the years. They show that the things go together, but they do not prove that one causes the other, and the authors themselves make a point of saying so. Whoever wants to defend the truth does not need to exaggerate the data. The picture is serious enough read with rigor.
The machine was designed to beat your brain
There is, however, one piece of data that does not depend on counting cases or on arguing about cause and effect. It is the point that changes the whole moral frame, and it is not opinion: it is what brain imaging shows.
Gambling uses the kind of reward that is hardest to give up of any psychology has ever measured: the one you do not know when it will come. A prize that always arrives at the same time is easy to walk away from; a prize with no set time is not. It is a design choice.
On top of this comes the near-miss effect. Brain imaging shows that near-misses activate the reward center with 75% to 90% of the strength of a real win. In plain terms: losing by a little is processed by the brain almost like winning, and the machines are designed to produce near-misses far more often than chance would. And there are the losses disguised as wins: when the payout is smaller than the bet placed, the machine still fires off lights, the sound of coins and a victory animation. The pocket records a loss; the brain records a win.
Now draw the conclusion. This is not the vice of people without willpower. It is a product designed by professionals to exploit a known neural mechanism.
And here the biblical accusation changes address. It leaves the gambler and goes to the one who sets the trap:
Then said he unto the disciples, It is impossible but that offences will come: but woe unto him, through whom they come! It were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and he cast into the sea, than that he should offend one of these little ones.Luke 17:1–2
The prophet was even more direct about those who profit from another’s fall: “Woe unto him that giveth his neighbour drink, that puttest thy bottle to him, and makest him drunken also” (Habakkuk 2:15).
The German court discovered what Jesus had already said
One piece is missing, and it comes from comparative law, because no court in the world decides whether betting is a sin, but some have decided something very close to it.
On March 28, 2006, the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany struck down Bavaria’s state monopoly on sports betting. Not for being a monopoly. The ground was different: the State may keep the whole market for itself only if it is really fighting addiction, and Bavaria was shutting out private companies without doing anything concrete against compulsive gambling. It wanted the revenue, not the protection. The court gave an ultimatum: either fight compulsive gambling for real, or open the market. There was no third way.
The Court of Justice of the European Union formalized this into a doctrine. Since the Gambelli case, in 2003, restrictions on gambling are justified only if they reduce opportunities “in a consistent and systematic manner.” And, in Markus Stoß and Carmen Media, the Court held16 that the State that encourages participation in other games loses the right to invoke the fight against addiction as a justification. In other words: incoherence stopped being merely ugly and became sufficient grounds for striking down the ban.
Now read this:
The Lord then answered him, and said, Thou hypocrite, doth not each one of you on the sabbath loose his ox or his ass from the stall, and lead him away to watering? And ought not this woman, being a daughter of Abraham, whom Satan hath bound, lo, these eighteen years, be loosed from this bond on the sabbath day?Luke 13:15–16
Notice what Jesus is doing, because it is not what is usually said. His accusation is not of excessive strictness. It is of incoherence. They loosed the ox and would not let the woman be loosed. They had one standard for their own loss and another for someone else’s pain. When Jesus calls them hypocrites, that is what he is naming: two weights for the same principle.
The German Constitutional Court demanded of the State exactly what Jesus demanded of the Pharisees. European law calls it consistency and system. Luke 13:15 calls it something else. And the question left over is whether the church that holds bingo in its hall and preaches against the betting sites would pass the test of either one.
The thesis: a wager is not a sin, gambling is
Enough beating around the bush. Here is the conclusion, and there is only one:
A wager is not a sin. Gambling is.
Games of chance are not a sin in themselves: they are an occasion of sin. And Scripture deals with occasions by principles, not by prohibitions. That is why seventeen centuries of the church condemned gambling so forcefully without being able to cite a verse: they were right in the diagnosis and clumsy in the grounding. They saw the ruin and invented the law that was missing, instead of applying the principles that were there in abundance. The principles are there in abundance, and there are five.
Mastery. “All things are lawful unto me, but all things are not expedient: all things are lawful for me, but I will not be brought under the power of any” (1 Corinthians 6:12). Paul gives the exact criterion: the problem is not lawfulness, it is being brought under its power. And that is literally what gambling disorder does.
Covetousness. “Thou shalt not covet” (Exodus 20:17) reaches desire, not only the act.
Stewardship. What we have was entrusted to us, and there will be an accounting: that is the logic of the parable of the talents (Matthew 25:14–30). Squandering what God entrusted is the reason Westminster classified gambling under “Thou shalt not steal.”17
Love of neighbor. In gambling, my gain is exactly your loss. There is no version in which both come out better, and that is what distinguishes it from commerce, from work, from insurance and from productive investment, in which the risk already existed and the contract merely manages it. In gambling, the risk is manufactured out of nothing to allow the transfer. This test, by the way, cuts both ways: by the same criterion, pure speculation falls too.
Anxiety. Jesus warned that the church would not fall through persecution but choked by “the cares of this world, and the deceitfulness of riches”, as in the parable of the sower (Mark 4:19). The promise of the betting sites is exactly that: the shortcut.
And the line, in practice, is not in the act. It is in three questions.
Who profits? If there is a house with a structural mathematical advantage, that is not a game between equals: it is extraction, the same figure as the masters who made their gain from the slave girl at Philippi and turned on the one who took their income away. It fails the fourth Catholic condition we saw back there, equality between the parties, and it fails love of neighbor.
Does it master you? If it rules your sleep, your budget or your mood, it is no longer lawful for you, whatever the amount.
Where does the gain come from? If it comes exactly from someone’s loss, and the risk was manufactured to allow the transfer, it is gambling, even if it is legal, state-run, regulated, or held in the church hall.
What to do, then
The position fits in one line: the wager is not forbidden, gambling is fought, and the church begins with itself.
In practice, that means six decisions, and none of them is silence.
1. Do not invent a commandment. If Scripture did not forbid it, the pulpit cannot forbid it in Scripture’s name. Whoever preaches “betting is a sin” affirms what the text does not affirm, and loses authority exactly where he most needs it. Imposing on another’s conscience what God did not impose is a direct offense against the liberty Christ purchased: it is the same error that the council of Jerusalem condemned when it refused to lay the yoke of the Law on the Gentiles, and Westminster says it in so many words.
2. Do not use liberty as an excuse. “There is no commandment” does not mean “I am cleared.” The absence of a law sends the question back to principle, and principle binds more than a rule, because it cannot be kept on the outside. When Jesus dealt with the Sabbath, he did not say the Sabbath did not matter. He said the purpose mattered more than the rule, which is a greater demand, not a lesser one.
3. Clean up your own hall before talking about the street. As long as the church fixes its roof with bingo, raffles and prize drawings, it has no voice against the betting sites, and the world notices. The fundraising method of God’s people is the free and cheerful offering: “Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver” (2 Corinthians 9:7). A raffle is not an offering: it is selling hope to ninety-nine so that one can take home the prize. Take bingo off the calendar before you take the betting sites out of the sermon.
4. Deal with mastery, not with the act. No one should be disciplined for having bet a lunch; and no one should be left alone because he “only plays a little” while he loses his paycheck, his sleep and his family. The criterion is Paul’s: “I will not be brought under the power of any” (1 Corinthians 6:12). The pastoral question is not how much he spent; it is who is in charge.
5. Receive the brother who thinks differently. In a matter Scripture has not closed, Romans 14 applies: the one who does not abstain must not despise the one who abstains, and the one who abstains must not judge the one who does not. Turning this into a test of fellowship is adding to the Word, and churches have split over less.
6. And care for the one who has fallen. There is evidence-based treatment: cognitive behavioral therapy, follow-up at a CAPS,18 support groups, and medication where indicated. The church that offers only prayer and shame is offering less than it can. Referring someone is a pastoral act, not a lack of faith.
One last thing, and it is to fix in your mind.
The data say that gambling does not spread the damage evenly. It concentrates it on the teenager, the poor and the head of the household. Those are exactly the three people sitting in the church pew.
And there is a scene that Scripture records and that we read too quickly. While God was dying on a cross, three meters away there was a game for money under way. Men casting lots for his coat, their backs to redemption, counting coins.
Then the soldiers, when they had crucified Jesus, took his garments, and made four parts, to every soldier a part; and also his coat: now the coat was without seam, woven from the top throughout. They said therefore among themselves, Let us not rend it, but cast lots for it, whose it shall be…John 19:23–24a
It is the only bet for money recorded in the New Testament. And it is not there by chance: it shows people busy transferring what belonged to another while salvation was happening behind their backs.
The church does not need to forbid what God did not forbid. It needs to say, plainly, what it knows: a wager is not a sin, gambling is, and the first table to be overturned is the one in our own church hall.
So, in one sentence: betting is not a sin, because God did not forbid it, but gambling is, and it begins the moment the risk stops being shared and starts being manufactured, when there is a house that cannot lose, when one person’s gain is born of another’s ruin, when the desire to receive without working becomes covetousness and when the habit starts to rule the one who plays.
The conclusion, then, is this, and it has no middle ground: the church must not invent a “thou shalt not bet” that Scripture did not write, and it must say, plainly, that the betting sites, the slot machine and the commercial lottery are gambling, because they fail the three tests, and that the Christian should not put money into them. Not because they are forbidden, but because they are an industry that lives by mastering, impoverishing and sickening precisely the teenager, the poor and the father of the family who are sitting in our pews.
In practice, pastor, this is what you take into Sunday. Preach that betting is not a sin, and that the brother who bet a lunch with a friend does not need to be shamed for it. Preach, in the same message, that the betting sites are something else: a house that cannot lose, living off the money of those who lose, and that the Christian does not go in there. Take bingo and raffles off the church calendar, and explain from the front why you are taking them off. Discipline no one for having placed a bet; but do seek out whoever is already mastered, and refer him for treatment as you would refer an alcoholic. And do not break fellowship with those who disagree, because Scripture did not close that door.
Liberty where God gave liberty, firmness where God gave principle, and coherence beginning at home.
Above all this, remember always to act in love, as it says: “have fervent charity among yourselves: for charity shall cover the multitude of sins” (1 Peter 4:8), where “charity” is the King James word for love.
Notes
1. ADPF (Claim of Non-Compliance with a Fundamental Precept) and ADI (Direct Action of Unconstitutionality) are the two main actions of abstract constitutional review in Brazil: in them the Supreme Court judges the law in the abstract, without a concrete case, and the decision applies to everyone.
2. Full text of the lists cited (King James Version). Romans 1:29–31: “Being filled with all unrighteousness, fornication, wickedness, covetousness, maliciousness; full of envy, murder, debate, deceit, malignity; whisperers, Backbiters, haters of God, despiteful, proud, boasters, inventors of evil things, disobedient to parents, Without understanding, covenantbreakers, without natural affection, implacable, unmerciful.” 1 Corinthians 6:9–10: “Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor abusers of themselves with mankind, Nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God.” Galatians 5:19–21: “Now the works of the flesh are manifest, which are these; Adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness, Idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulations, wrath, strife, seditions, heresies, Envyings, murders, drunkenness, revellings, and such like: of the which I tell you before, as I have also told you in time past, that they which do such things shall not inherit the kingdom of God.” Ephesians 5:3–5: “But fornication, and all uncleanness, or covetousness, let it not be once named among you, as becometh saints; Neither filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting, which are not convenient: but rather giving of thanks. For this ye know, that no whoremonger, nor unclean person, nor covetous man, who is an idolater, hath any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God.” Colossians 3:5–8: “Mortify therefore your members which are upon the earth; fornication, uncleanness, inordinate affection, evil concupiscence, and covetousness, which is idolatry: For which things’ sake the wrath of God cometh on the children of disobedience: In the which ye also walked some time, when ye lived in them. But now ye also put off all these; anger, wrath, malice, blasphemy, filthy communication out of your mouth.” 1 Timothy 1:9–10: “Knowing this, that the law is not made for a righteous man, but for the lawless and disobedient, for the ungodly and for sinners, for unholy and profane, for murderers of fathers and murderers of mothers, for manslayers, For whoremongers, for them that defile themselves with mankind, for menstealers, for liars, for perjured persons, and if there be any other thing that is contrary to sound doctrine.” Revelation 21:8: “But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death.” Revelation 22:15: “For without are dogs, and sorcerers, and whoremongers, and murderers, and idolaters, and whosoever loveth and maketh a lie.”
3. Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter 20, paragraph 2, quoted above in its original wording. The “beside it” (outside it, apart from it) is what reaches the invented prohibition, and not only the contrary one.
4. The Greek term is κυβεία (kubeia), from κύβος (kubos), the die. It occurs only once in the New Testament, in Ephesians 4:14, already with the derived sense of trickery and cunning.
5. Apostolic Canons 41 and 42; Council of Elvira, canon 79; Quinisext Council (in Trullo, 692), canon 50. Saint Nicodemus the Hagiorite, commenting on canon 50 in the Pedalion, extends the prohibition to “dice, cards, checkers or any other similar game” (our translation).
6. De Aleatoribus was long attributed to Cyprian of Carthage; modern scholarship tends to attribute it to a bishop of Rome of the second or third century: Victor I, Callistus I or Miltiades.
7. Tertullian (c. 155–220), of Carthage, was the first great Christian author to write in Latin. The De Spectaculis is his treatise against the public spectacles of the Empire: circus, arena and theater.
8. Cyprian (c. 200–258) was bishop of Carthage and died a martyr. He and Tertullian are among the so-called Fathers of the Church: the writers of the first centuries whose testimony documents ancient Christian practice. The phrase quoted from Cyprian is our translation.
9. The four conditions are the classic formulation of the Catholic moralists, summarized in the article “Gambling” in the Catholic Encyclopedia: legitimate ownership of the thing staked, freedom of action, absence of fraud and equality between the parties.
10. Charles Haddon Spurgeon (1834–1892), a British Baptist pastor whom his contemporaries called “the prince of preachers.” The Metropolitan Tabernacle, in London, was his church, with an auditorium for about six thousand people.
11. Sermon No. 2228, The Law’s Failure and Fulfilment, on Romans 8:3–4, preached at the Metropolitan Tabernacle on March 1, 1891. The full passage: “I noticed, some time ago, that a learned prelate said that he could not find any commandment against gambling. Where were his eyes? Is it not plainly written, ‘Thou shalt not covet’? What is gambling but covetousness in action?”
12. Unifesp: Federal University of São Paulo. Senad: National Secretariat for Drug Policy, the federal government agency that funded the survey.
13. IEPS (Institute for Health Policy Studies) is an independent, nonprofit organization devoted to research and to the formulation of public health policy in Brazil. Umane is a civil association, also nonprofit, that funds public health initiatives aimed at the SUS (Brazil’s public health system); it took part in the study as funder, not as author of the analysis.
14. DSM-5: fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, of the American Psychiatric Association, published in 2013. It is the main international reference for the classification of mental disorders.
15. ICD-11: 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases, in force since 2022. It is the official list of diagnoses adopted by health systems, including Brazil’s.
16. Gambelli (2003), Markus Stoß (2010) and Carmen Media (2010) are judgments of the Court of Justice of the European Union on state gambling monopolies. The names correspond to the parties who challenged the national restrictions.
17. Westminster Larger Catechism, questions 112, 113 and 142. Question 142 lists wasteful gaming among the sins forbidden in the eighth commandment; in seventeenth-century English, gaming specifically meant gambling for money.
18. CAPS: Psychosocial Care Centers, free public services of the SUS (Brazil’s public health system) devoted to mental disorders and addictions, present in most municipalities.